Are executives worth their huge pay packets?
Published: 15th Sep 2010 23:51:24
A disgruntled shareholder at the Cable and Wireless AGMs earlier this summer was clearly ready to voice her anger.
"All the money and all the profit seem to be going toward the salaries of the board and I didn't necessarily think that they were worth that amount of money," she says.
The woman seemed to be echoing the sentiments of many of her fellow shareholders.
And in recent years, particularly since the start of the banking crisis, her concern has been widely shared across the country too.
But why has pay for people at the top got so high? Do they really earn it? Do we need to pay it?
Management writer David Bolchover certainly does not think so. He believes high pay is sustained by an ideology that he calls the "talent myth".
"The 'talent myth' states that there are a small proportion of high flying employees who make a huge impact on their companies success and that those employees are extremely difficult to replace," he says.
But lots of people have the characteristics needed to be successful, Mr Bolchover insists, so why should they be so hard to replace?
How much do people in different jobs earn?
The answer, he reasons, is that there is a whole industry consisting of other high-paid people, institutional shareholders, pay consultants, even journalists and academics who have a vested interest in sustaining high pay.
Many might disagree with parts of Mr Bolchover's analysis, but it seems there is also widespread acceptance of the notion that too much money is being paid out.
Yet it happens, in many different ways.
Kit Bingham, who recruits top people for executive head-hunters Odgers Berndtson, says one of the biggest problems is companies being forced to declare how much they pay their top executives.
"A chief executive can turn to his board and say 'look, I'm far better than Joe Bloggs in my peer group over there, and look he's being paid 25% more than me. Why is this? I demand an increase!'"
Moreover, Mr Bingham reasons, companies need to persuade the City that they are ambitious.
One way of doing that is to try and recruit top people, paying top salaries, even if the person is not actually a top person in reality, he explains.
Jon Terry, head of reward at Pricewaterhouse Coopers, says there are also problems within companies.
Weak or low-quality remuneration committees setting vague or unchallenging bonus targets can easily allow high bonuses to be paid, even when companies have performed poorly.
And company shareholders are not always interested, either.
Many are based overseas and even some of those based in the UK "do not see companies as things that are necessarily generating wealth for the economy, but as things that they just buy and sell and trade", according to Sarah Wilson, head of Manifest, which advises institutional investors on how to vote on such things as executive pay.
In other words, there is a "pay bubble", and the benchmarking, targets and bonuses that have contributed to it in the private sector are now familiar across the public and voluntary sectors.
Over the last decade or so, the biggest source of the growth of high pay and wider inequality has been bonuses, according to some recent research.
And those who have benefited have been "the people [already] within the top 10%, and then even within that group the top 5% and the top 1%" of the income scale, according to Brian Bell, a Research Fellow at the London School of Economics' Centre for Economic Performance.
Most of them are based in London where they work in the financial sector, have… essentially run away from the rest of the workers."
But bonuses do not even work as intended, according to Professor Dan Ariely, a leading behavioural economist.
His research shows that while people jump higher or perform better on manual tasks if they are offered greater rewards, "on tasks that require concentration, thinking, memory, any kind of cognitive skills… the more money we put in front of people, the worse they do".
A recipe for direct intervention to curb executive pay may be emerging.
Will Hutton, who has been asked by the government to explore introducing a 20:1 pay multiple in the public sector, says if it works there it could easily be adopted elsewhere too.
"Hopefully this produces a high performance and high morale public sector," he says.
And if that happens, he predicts private sector companies might well respond by trying something similar themselves.
Can Pay, Will Pay, is on Radio 4 at 0900 BST on Thursday 16 September, and on Friday 17 September.
At 09:08:12 in EnglandA Kent dockyard that 100 years ago formed a key naval base is staging an exhibition looking at how World War One was fought at sea.
At 09:03:34 in EnglandOne of the largest population studies in the world now wants the grandparents of the original children to join in.
At 09:00:24 in Northern IrelandA company that plans to use fracking to extract natural gas in County Fermanagh has said it has obtained an injunction to prevent unlawful access to a quarry.
At 08:57:46 in SportChelsea boss Jose Mourinho claims he pulled out of a bid to sign left-back Luke Shaw this summer because his wage demands would have "killed" the club.
At 08:53:33 in ScotlandA woman has been airlifted to hospital following a crash in the Highlands involving a minibus.
At 08:23:18 in WalesFriends of a 73-year-old Denbigh man missing in Crete say they hope to find a lead as they mount a search for him.
At 08:12:13 in SportRhythmic gymnasts Frankie Jones and Laura Halford have the chance to win Wales' first gold medal of the Commonwealth Games on Saturday.
At 08:05:01 in EnglandRail passengers in parts of southern England and Wales are facing further travel problems after stormy weather caused "major disruption" on Friday.
At 07:42:42 in EnglandResidents have raised more than £60,000 to keep a sculpture that was on loan to their County Durham town.
At 07:22:48 in EnglandThe 200th anniversary of Britain's oldest seaside pier is being celebrated this weekend.
Harvard CitationBBC News, 2010. Are executives worth their huge pay packets? [Online] (Updated 15th Sep 2010)
Available at: http://www.ukwirednews.com/news/90551/Are-executives-worth-their-huge-pay-packets [Accessed 26th Jul 2014]
News In Other Categories
Rail passengers in parts of southern England and Wales are facing further travel problems after stormy weather caused "major disruption" on Friday.
Several big names have pulled out of the Commonwealth Games in the past few weeks with injuries and illness.
Friends of a 73-year-old Denbigh man missing in Crete say they hope to find a lead as they mount a search for him.
Chelsea boss Jose Mourinho claims he pulled out of a bid to sign left-back Luke Shaw this summer because his wage demands would have "killed" the club.
A woman has been airlifted to hospital following a crash in the Highlands involving a minibus.
It's exactly half a century since the premiere of Fiddler on the Roof - among the most successful stage musicals written to date. In 1964 Sheldon Harnick and his colleagues worried that the setting, a small Jewish township in eastern Europe in the early 1900s, might limit the show's appeal. But, says Harnick, the show's real subject is a universal one - family.