Action video gamers better at making quick decisions
Published: 14th Sep 2010 10:59:46
Action video game enthusiasts are better quick-fire decision-makers, according to researchers.
Gamers presented with both audio and visual tests proved better than non-gamers at a simple choice-making task.
Even non-gamers who played action games for 50 hours as part of the experiment picked up the decision-making skills.
The research, published in Current Biology, adds to the group's prior findings that gamers have more acute attention spans than non-gamers.
Other research has shown that video gameplay improves aspects of vision, including visual memory, and the ability to change between mental tasks quickly.
What has remained unclear is if there is any connection between these disparate findings, explained Shawn Green, lead author of the new work.
"The current paper asks... is video game training really teaching a lot of individual skills, or is there one single mechanistic explanation that underlies all of the effects?," Dr Green told BBC News.
"We argue in the paper that it is the latter: one single mechanistic explanation - an improvement in probabilistic inference - that explains why video game training enhances performance on so many very different tasks."
This "probabilistic inference" is in essence the degree to which assimilating many small pieces of information leads to good decisions.
"Because there is uncertainty in the world, and in our ability as humans to measure and understand the world, the best we can do when making decisions is to compute how each little snippet of evidence we receive changes the probability that the various alternatives available to us are the correct option," Dr Green explained.
To put gamers' and non-gamers' probabilistic inference to the test, the team, led by Rochester's Daphne Bavelier, came up with two experiments - one visual and one auditory.
In the visual test, an array of dots was made to move, on the whole, in one direction or another. Participants were asked to choose which direction they thought the field of dots was moving, with the task made more difficult by varying the degree to which the dots moved in synchrony.
The auditory test included a series of noises, with participants asked to guess which ear was receiving the target sound among a great deal of noise.
Both tasks require the accumulation of clues, because the answers were not immediately clear.
The team found that avowed gamers were significantly faster at coming up with the right answer than non-gamers.
"We found that in both tasks, video game players made their decisions much faster than non-video game players, but with an equivalent level of accuracy - thus showing that the video game players weren't just 'trigger happy', which would have led to a decrease in accuracy," Dr Green said.
"Fitting the data with a neural model indicated that the video game player results could be explained if they were performing better probabilistic inference - in essence, every little dot or sound was telling them more about the correct answer than the exact same dot or sound was telling the non-video game players."
Jeffrey Goldstein of Utrecht University's Department of Social and Organizational Psychology pointed out the group's long-established experimental approach of allowing non-gamers to practise games for tens of hours, saying that it eliminates the question of correlations and causality.
That is, the results show that gamers have improved skill, rather than those with improved skills tend to be gamers.
"In order to eliminate the problem of correlations, she trains people to see whether they improve," Professor Goldstein told BBC News.
"She can argue pretty convincingly that playing these games is a cause of improved skills, however they're defined."
Dan Pinchbeck, a games researcher from the University of Portsmouth in the UK, said the results were something "not many gamers would disagree with", saying the fact that the result was limited to action games - rather than, for example, slower-moving role-playing games - might reflect the very skills that action games hone.
However, he said the paper's line of research promised much understanding yet to come.
"It's such early days for this kind of stuff in relation to games," Dr Pinchbeck told BBC News.
"What's really important is that we're seeing hard scientific data get attached to the understanding of games; we're not working just on opinion and unsubstantiated theory - that's critical.
"We need more on the table to paint an accurate picture of what's going on with gamers, but these are tantalising hints of what could be out there."
At 00:58:56 in BusinessAustralia's national flag carrier Qantas has reported a net loss of A$2.8bn ($2.6bn; £1.57bn) for the year ending in June - its biggest ever financial loss.
At 00:55:08 in ScotlandThe UK is "an economy of opportunity" which supports one million Scottish jobs, David Cameron is to tell business leaders.
At 00:09:38 in WorldRussia has consistently denied sending tanks into Ukraine, arguing that any vehicles used by separatist forces there must have been captured from the Ukrainian army itself.
At 00:03:38 in SportBritish number one Andy Murray and German qualifier Matthias Bachinger will take centre stage in the night session at the US Open on Friday.
At 00:03:08 in SportArsenal join Manchester City, Chelsea and Liverpool in Thursday's draw for the Champions League groups.
At 00:00:24 in WorldFour male college students at the University of North Carolina are developing a new kind of nail polish that changes colour in the presence of date-rape drugs, like GHB and Rohypnol.
At 23:59:52 in EnglandThe under-pressure Police and Crime Commissioner (PCC) for South Yorkshire has quit the Labour Party but has said he will not step down as commissioner.
At 23:42:29 in HeadlinesA crew member on an US police reality TV show has been shot and killed after Nebraska police opened fire on a robbery suspect.
At 23:35:58 in Northern IrelandA woman aged in her 50s has died in a car crash in Carrickfergus, County Antrim.
At 23:25:38 in WorldSouth Korea is agonising over the death of one soldier and a deadly shooting spree by another.
Harvard CitationBBC News, 2010. Action video gamers better at making quick decisions [Online] (Updated 14th Sep 2010)
Available at: http://www.ukwirednews.com/news/90028/Action-video-gamers-better-at-making-quick-decisions [Accessed 28th Aug 2014]
News In Other Categories
Records of landmark US civil rights cases presided over by one of the country's most senior judges have been removed from the internet.
A crew member on an US police reality TV show has been shot and killed after Nebraska police opened fire on a robbery suspect.
The under-pressure Police and Crime Commissioner (PCC) for South Yorkshire has quit the Labour Party but has said he will not step down as commissioner.
Australia's national flag carrier Qantas has reported a net loss of A$2.8bn ($2.6bn; £1.57bn) for the year ending in June - its biggest ever financial loss.
The UK is "an economy of opportunity" which supports one million Scottish jobs, David Cameron is to tell business leaders.
The government is set to threaten to stop buying some expensive cancer drugs if manufacturers do not cut their prices, Newsnight has learned.