Masterchef defends souffle shots
Published: 17th Feb 2012 17:14:20
Any suggestion that a Masterchef contestant was allowed several attempts to cook a souffle after it was shown deflated and then perfectly risen is "completely untrue", the BBC has said.
On 1 February, contestant Tom Rennolds was filmed presenting a fallen souffle to judges John Torode and Greg Wallace.
Wallace was then shown tucking into a risen souffle, declaring it "lovely".
The BBC said it "naturally deflated" by judging time but producers had cut back to a shot taken "as it was plated up".
"We always shoot the souffles as soon as time is called and cooking is finished," the corporation said in a statement.
"Then filming of the judging continues, by which time souffles have naturally deflated."
"This doesn't affect the tasting or judging at all as the souffle taste remains the same and, of course, the judges have seen how it looks when first plated up."
The BBC made its statement after several newspapers wrote that the corporation had been "accused of faking scenes" in the show, although it was unclear who had made the accusations.
It has received no complaints about the programme.
At the start of the sequence, Rennolds, a 26-year-old plasterer from Silsden, West Yorkshire, was shown placing his collapsed chilli and pineapple souffle in front of the judges.
There then followed close-up shots of the risen souffle, before a spoon was shown being placed into the perfect pudding.
In the next shot, Wallace was shown taking a spoonful of the deflated dessert, before further shots of the unspoiled pudding were shown.
"That's lovely, that's lovely - dainty, elegant, beautiful," Wallace said.
"Stunning, absolutely stunning - as light as a feather," Wallace's critique continued. "Sunshine sweet of pineapple and a little bit of chilli heat prickling your tongue. Stunning."
The BBC said contestants were always allowed to make more than one souffle.
"As time is called at the end of cooking they must put only one up to be filmed, tasted and judged," the statement added.
"We always cut back to the shot of the food as it was when first plated up as a reminder of how the dish looked before the tasting."
Tom Rennolds remains a contender in this year's Masterchef, which will conclude next month.
At 05:57:50 in HeadlinesIssues around pensions are back on the front pages, with the Daily Express reporting that people are "topping up" retirement incomes by releasing equity from their properties.
At 05:15:55 in SportRed Bull's Daniel Ricciardo set the pace during an inconclusive wet final practice at the Chinese Grand Prix.
At 05:11:00 in WalesA 21-year-old man has fallen to his death near Mount Snowdon, according to North Wales Police.
At 05:04:45 in Northern IrelandNorthern Ireland's first and deputy first ministers have condemned the west Belfast killing of a prominent dissident republican.
At 04:25:00 in HeadlinesThe captain of a South Korean ferry that sank this week said he delayed giving evacuation orders because he feared passengers would "drift away".
At 04:13:32 in PoliticsA government minister has written to schools and local authorities in England urging a more common sense approach to health and safety.
At 03:56:18 in EnglandA 50-year-old gardener accused of having a pump action rifle and ammunition is due to appear before magistrates later.
At 03:47:19 in HeadlinesA Brazilian second division football game has been abandoned after 16 minutes, with one of the teams saying they now have a court order to play in the top division.
At 02:47:25 in BusinessWhether it is for its generous staff bonus or its Christmas advert, John Lewis has recently the been the subject of many good-news headlines. As the partnership celebrates 150 years since it opened its first store in central London how has it transformed?
At 02:35:58 in HeadlinesThe UN has expressed outrage at a deadly attack on one of its bases in South Sudan, saying it could "constitute a war crime".
Harvard CitationBBC News, 2012. Masterchef defends souffle shots [Online] (Updated 17th Feb 2012)
Available at: http://www.ukwirednews.com/news/226093/Masterchef-defends-souffle-shots [Accessed 19th Apr 2014]
News In Other Categories
How do you tell the world about your remote-controlled flying fish toys?
Northern Ireland's first and deputy first ministers have condemned the west Belfast killing of a prominent dissident republican.
Delivering mail to Scotland's 94 inhabited islands - not to mention hundreds of remote communities in the Highlands - is an expensive business.
Whether it is for its generous staff bonus or its Christmas advert, John Lewis has recently the been the subject of many good-news headlines. As the partnership celebrates 150 years since it opened its first store in central London how has it transformed?
Susanne du Toit won last year's BP Portrait Prize, one of the UK's most prestigious visual arts awards.