Masterchef defends souffle shots
Published: 17th Feb 2012 17:14:20
Any suggestion that a Masterchef contestant was allowed several attempts to cook a souffle after it was shown deflated and then perfectly risen is "completely untrue", the BBC has said.
On 1 February, contestant Tom Rennolds was filmed presenting a fallen souffle to judges John Torode and Greg Wallace.
Wallace was then shown tucking into a risen souffle, declaring it "lovely".
The BBC said it "naturally deflated" by judging time but producers had cut back to a shot taken "as it was plated up".
"We always shoot the souffles as soon as time is called and cooking is finished," the corporation said in a statement.
"Then filming of the judging continues, by which time souffles have naturally deflated."
"This doesn't affect the tasting or judging at all as the souffle taste remains the same and, of course, the judges have seen how it looks when first plated up."
The BBC made its statement after several newspapers wrote that the corporation had been "accused of faking scenes" in the show, although it was unclear who had made the accusations.
It has received no complaints about the programme.
At the start of the sequence, Rennolds, a 26-year-old plasterer from Silsden, West Yorkshire, was shown placing his collapsed chilli and pineapple souffle in front of the judges.
There then followed close-up shots of the risen souffle, before a spoon was shown being placed into the perfect pudding.
In the next shot, Wallace was shown taking a spoonful of the deflated dessert, before further shots of the unspoiled pudding were shown.
"That's lovely, that's lovely - dainty, elegant, beautiful," Wallace said.
"Stunning, absolutely stunning - as light as a feather," Wallace's critique continued. "Sunshine sweet of pineapple and a little bit of chilli heat prickling your tongue. Stunning."
The BBC said contestants were always allowed to make more than one souffle.
"As time is called at the end of cooking they must put only one up to be filmed, tasted and judged," the statement added.
"We always cut back to the shot of the food as it was when first plated up as a reminder of how the dish looked before the tasting."
Tom Rennolds remains a contender in this year's Masterchef, which will conclude next month.
At 20:55:13 in HeadlinesA top Venezuelan official, Gen Hugo Carvajal, has been detained in the Dutch Caribbean island of Aruba at the request of the American government.
At 20:49:32 in EnglandA man has died after wading into a lake on Tyneside.
At 20:44:50 in EnglandA man who denies murdering a sports coach has told a court the victim swung a dumbbell at him during the confrontation.
At 20:36:06 in EnglandA cat reported missing a week ago in Lincolnshire has been rescued from a chimney after it was heard crying.
At 20:34:50 in BusinessThe South African government has announced plans to fast-track a bill barring foreigners from buying land.
At 20:29:16 in HeadlinesA man charged with killing an unarmed black woman on his suburban Detroit porch in November initially told police it was an accident, a jury has heard.
At 20:16:26 in SportBernhard Langer opened with a six-under-par 65 to take a two-stroke lead over American Bob Tway in the Senior Open Championship at Royal Porthcawl.
At 20:06:57 in EnglandA husband from Dorset has won High Court damages of more than £600,000 for the "loss of services" provided by his "extremely house-proud" wife.
At 19:47:12 in SportMichael Conlan and Steven Ward are among the Northern Ireland boxers entering the fray at the Commonwealth Games in Glasgow on Friday.
At 19:43:03 in EnglandThe family of a severely autistic teenager says it is hopeful he will return home to Cornwall after a minister criticised his care plan.
Harvard CitationBBC News, 2012. Masterchef defends souffle shots [Online] (Updated 17th Feb 2012)
Available at: http://www.ukwirednews.com/news/226093/Masterchef-defends-souffle-shots [Accessed 24th Jul 2014]
News In Other Categories
Bernhard Langer opened with a six-under-par 65 to take a two-stroke lead over American Bob Tway in the Senior Open Championship at Royal Porthcawl.
A top Venezuelan official, Gen Hugo Carvajal, has been detained in the Dutch Caribbean island of Aruba at the request of the American government.
A man has died after wading into a lake on Tyneside.
The Republic of Ireland abstained from a vote to hold an official investigation into alleged war crimes in Gaza because it wanted swifter action using existing mechanisms, its foreign minister has said.
A drugs mule from Ayr has been jailed for three years after he admitted attempting to smuggle heroin worth almost £13,000 into Shetland.
Taxpayers could be hit with a bill for up to £700m after the government reportedly lost a legal battle with Fujitsu over a failed NHS IT system.