Northern Ireland peers oppose House of Lords plan
Category: Northern Ireland
Published: 24th Jan 2012 06:58:51
A number of peers from Northern Ireland have criticised plans to reform the House of Lords.
The Coalition government wants the second chamber, which has a membership of about 800, cut down to 300.
Under the changes the majority of the new members would be elected.
However, critics have said an elected Lords could challenge the Commons authority and say the reforms will not work.
Lord Eames, who sits as a crossbencher, said he feared tensions between the Commons and the Upper House if elections take place.
He is against a totally elected Lords and argued that appointees from a variety of different backgrounds bring much experience to the second chamber.
He is worried that elections would end opportunities to draw "on that expertise".
Baroness Paisley is another local peer who has serious misgivings about elections. She said having two chambers, where members are elected, could be "confusing".
She said it would be wrong to create a "replica of the House of Commons".
Coalition ministers want to cut the Lords to just 300 mostly-elected members as part of a radical reform of parliament.
Out of the 300 members, 240 would be elected with the remainder appointed.
However, there is now a debate over whether the figure of 300 is too low.
Earlier this month, a joint committee of MPs and peers examining the plans concluded that the Lords should have about 450 members.
Some 788 peers are currently able to sit and vote in the House of Lords, but in practice only about 400 are regular attenders.
Campaigners for change have said their argument is simple.
Those in favour of reform say politicians who make laws should be elected.
As many peers are against the moves the introduction of these measures will rest on the government's ability to get the reforms through the House of Commons.
Under the planned changes new members would be elected for a 15-year term of office. That particular proposal has been criticised by Lord Empey.
The former Ulster Unionist leader said that length of time would make them "unaccountable".
He believes an elected second chamber would question the authority of the House of Commons.
However, Lord Tyler, a Lib Dem peer who sits on on the joint committee said that since elections to the new chamber would take place in phases, the electoral mandate of the Commons would not be threatened.
Some critics also suggest that the reform plan has not been properly researched.
Baroness O'Loan, who sits as an independent and applied to be a member of the Lords, is unhappy about the speed of the debate.
She told the BBC: "I don't think it is going to work."
She added: "When you rush things as big as this - the odds are you will fail."
A committee of MPs and peers is expected to report back in March and campaigners for change hope the moves are included in the Queens Speech this summer.
If the plans are adopted by parliament, historic elections to the second chamber will take place in 2015.
At 04:53:55 in HeadlinesIran has cut state subsidies on petrol in a move that saw prices rise at midnight by up to 75%.
At 04:41:10 in Headlines
At 04:36:51 in Business
At 04:10:36 in Business
At 03:47:29 in Headlines
At 03:35:43 in World
At 03:28:21 in HeadlinesUK science is to get one of the biggest, most capable polar research vessels in the world.
At 03:22:33 in EnglandAs Liverpool fans dare to dream of a first league title in 24 years the club has revealed its own lofty plans for their ground.
At 03:10:58 in PoliticsPeople in Scotland will decide in September whether the country should become independent. A Yes vote would mean changes at Westminster, starting with the number of MPs:
At 02:53:41 in HeadlinesBrazilian police have clashed with residents of a Rio de Janeiro shantytown that was hit by deadly protests on Tuesday.
Harvard CitationBBC News, 2012. Northern Ireland peers oppose House of Lords plan [Online] (Updated 24th Jan 2012)
Available at: http://www.ukwirednews.com/news/220185/Northern-Ireland-peers-oppose-House-of-Lords-plan [Accessed 25th Apr 2014]
News In Other Categories
A new online map of England and Wales allows people to enter their postcode and find their community's risk of developing 14 conditions, such as heart disease and lung cancer.
As Liverpool fans dare to dream of a first league title in 24 years the club has revealed its own lofty plans for their ground.
A village museum in East Sussex will go up against Tate Britain and the new £35m Mary Rose Museum in a contest to be named the UK's museum of the year.
Four of the biggest technology firms - Apple, Google, Intel and Adobe - have settled a class action lawsuit alleging they conspired to hold down salaries.