Analysis: DR Congo elections open new wounds
Published: 20th Dec 2011 07:41:39
Democratic Republic of Congo President Joseph Kabila's victory in the 28 November election is fragile and contested.
His swearing-in ceremony is scheduled for Tuesday. But main opposition leader Etienne Tshisekedi, 79, will also be sworn in as president "by the people" on Friday at a mass rally Martyrs' stadium in the capital, Kinshasa.
People voted, votes were counted - but we don't know who is in control. DR Congo - two-thirds the size of Western Europe - is headed for a period of institutional sluggishness and isolation in the West.
An incumbent entourage that is likely to continue pillaging the country's resources opposes an aged runner-up with a political ego larger than his capacity to propose a constructive political agenda.
Even before outside observers cast doubts on the veracity of the results, Mr Tshisekedi cried foul, unilaterally declaring himself president.
Mr Tshisekedi is the charismatic leader of the Union for Democracy and Social Progress (UDPS), a historically important political movement.
Europe and the US have relatively little leverage over President Joseph Kabila because DR Congo has the natural resources that the world needs”
Kinshasa then braced itself for mass uprisings. But the doomsday scenario did not unfold.
DR Congo's demonstrators do not want to be martyrs like those of the Arab world.
The fear of winding up in The Hague at the International Criminal Court (ICC) calmed tempers.
Like the announcements by the election commission and the Supreme Court, Mr Kabila's ceremony is likely to be a non event.
The foreign minister of former colonial power Belgium, Didier Reynders, will not attend.
He accused the Supreme Court of not having examined the results thoroughly enough when confirming Mr Kabila's victory with 49% of the vote to Mr Tshisekedi's 32%.
Other Western governments are likely to follow suit because they often take Belgian cues as to what diplomatic stance to take towards Kinshasa.
Mr Reynders' position is a slight embarrassment to Mr Kabila but doesn't really count for much.
Europe and the US have relatively little leverage over him because DR Congo has the natural resources that the world needs.
Barter deals made in recent years with China are proof. China is rehabilitating Congolese infrastructure in exchange for favourable mining contracts.
The opposition was fragmented during the electoral campaign and suffered from their inability to agree on a common opposition candidate.
But there are now hints that the opposition may finally be tying to forge a united position.
Mr Tshisekedi is not going to bow down to Mr Kabila or be shoehorned into a power-sharing arrangement”
Mr Tshisekedi wields popular support, particularly in the two Kasai provinces and in Kinshasa.
He has more to win by peaceful action than by inciting violent street movements.
A group of peaceful demonstrators with bible in hand is more powerful in the Congolese context than mobs throwing stones.
His capacity to badger Mr Kabila cannot be underestimated.
Pockets of the country could follow him, putting pressure on the central government's capacity to levy taxes and control territory, blemishing Kinshasa's reputation nationally and internationally.
Mr Tshisekedi destabilized ex-dictator Mobutu Sese Seko in the early 1990s by organizing peaceful Christian marches and general strikes, earning himself the nickname Moses. People saw him as a saviour.
Kasai, also under his impetus, refused Mr Mobutu's five million Zaire banknote, putting further pressure on the dictator.
This success helped overshadow a skeleton in his closet: He was an actor in the assassination of DR Congo's first independence leader, Patrice Lumumba. According to Ludo De Witte's book The Assassination of Lumumba, Mr Tshisekedi has not commented on the allegation.
Mr Tshisekedi is not going to bow down to Mr Kabila or be shoehorned into a power-sharing arrangement.
He can take advantage of Mr Kabila's vulnerability in Kinshasa.
Imagine President Barack Obama being persona non grata in Washington DC. That is Mr Kabila's situation in the city that is the seat of the country's institutions.
The risk of an even worse investment climate also weakens Mr Kabila.
The Dutch brewery Heineken, which keeps the beer flowing in DR Congo, or US mining company Freeport-McMoRan Copper & Gold Inc, for example, could find themselves under pressure by shareholders sensitive to the problems of paying taxes to a government seen as illegitimate.
Mr Tshisekedi is also stubborn and unpredictable.
This explains why Western diplomats and businessmen actually prefer to have Mr Kabila wearing the emperor's clothes.
Despite certain problems with him - such as the lack of investment security in the mining sector - he does represent a sense of continuity.
When Mr Tshisekedi, 79, dies, most observers believe, the UDPS will wither away.
Mr Kabila, 40, could improve his legitimacy by investing some of the country's wealth into improved macroeconomic management and social programmes - even as a benevolent dictator.
The country has its own resources to do so and could rely on continued international aid if human rights and investment conditions are improved. This depends on political will.
Alternatively, he could govern the country as a reclusive and unpopular strongman catering to opportunistic business partners. Another revision of the constitution, prolonging his mandate or legalizing a third term, is not to be excluded.
As the stalemate drags on, Congolese people continue to pay the price.
Theodore Trefon is senior researcher at the Royal Museum for Central Africa and author of the blog Congo Masquerade: The political culture of aid inefficiency and reform failure.
The Democratic Republic of Congo covers 2,344,858 square km of land in the centre of Africa, making it the 12th largest country in the world.
At 23:02:05 in BusinessE-commerce giant eBay has cut the total compensation of its chief executive, John Donahoe, by more than half.
At 22:54:15 in WorldRishang Keishing still remembers the first time he travelled to work as a newly elected MP in India's first parliament, in 1952.
At 22:42:43 in SportThe Irish Premiership looks set to have no representation in the Setanta Sports Cup semi-finals after Coleraine, Crusaders and Ballinamallard United lost their two-leg quarter-final ties.
At 22:13:00 in SportJohn Hughes has told his Inverness CT players that Wednesday's game against Hibs is their opportunity to impress ahead of the Scottish League Cup final.
At 22:12:21 in SportTwo goals in the dying minutes of the game earned Glenavon a dramatic last-gasp Irish Cup quarter-final win over Glentoran at the Oval on Monday night.
At 22:09:29 in EnglandPolice control rooms in Cambridgeshire, Hertfordshire and Bedfordshire could be run by one force HQ to save millions of pounds, the BBC has learned.
At 22:02:04 in EnglandThere are significant variations across England and Wales in the way police and prosecutors deal with cases of domestic violence, figures show.
At 22:00:06 in EnglandA car ploughed through the front of a shop after a crash in Greater Manchester.
At 21:53:55 in WorldSome Caribbean nations are demanding reparations from Europe over the Atlantic slave trade. But slavery still happens today - film director Steve McQueen said at the Academy Awards there are 21 million slaves worldwide. Is that figure correct?
At 21:42:03 in WorldLibyan officials say they have taken control of a North Korean-flagged tanker that loaded crude oil at a port occupied by rebel forces.
Harvard CitationBBC News, 2011. Analysis: DR Congo elections open new wounds [Online] (Updated 20th Dec 2011)
Available at: http://www.ukwirednews.com/news/211879/Analysis-DR-Congo-elections-open-new-wounds [Accessed 10th Mar 2014]
News In Other Categories
E-commerce giant eBay has cut the total compensation of its chief executive, John Donahoe, by more than half.
Police have reported three people to the procurator fiscal and warned a further six after a crackdown on illegal motorcyclists in Fife.
American writer George Saunders has won the inaugural Folio Prize for his "darkly playful" short story collection, Tenth of December.
Two wallabies have escaped from privately-owned land in County Down and police have warned the public not to approach the animals.
Police control rooms in Cambridgeshire, Hertfordshire and Bedfordshire could be run by one force HQ to save millions of pounds, the BBC has learned.
A Japanese scientist behind a seemingly groundbreaking stem cell study says the findings should be withdrawn amid doubts over its quality.