Kimberley Hainey trial: Toddler death reason 'unclear'
Published: 23rd Nov 2011 13:58:09
The trial of a woman accused of murdering her 23-month-old son has been told that no-one knows why he died.
Pathologist Dr Claire Evans was giving evidence at the High Court in Glasgow, where Kimberley Hainey is on trial.
Under questioning, Dr Evans admitted there could have been a number of "natural causes" for Declan's death.
Ms Hainey, 37, of Johnstone, Paisley, denies murdering the child, concealing his body and pretending he was alive to avoid a police investigation.
The court heard that Dr Evans is a consultant paediatric and perinatal pathologist at Yorkhill Hospital, Glasgow.
Dr Evans and another pathologist, Dr Julie McAdam, carried out a post mortem examination on Declan after his body was found in his cot at his home in Bruce Road, Paisley, on 30 March 2010.
He had been dead for months and his body was mummified.
With a child under 18 months it could come under sudden death syndrome”
Dr Evans told advocate depute Andrew Stewart QC that there was evidence that Declan had been fed prior to his death.
Toxicology reports showed that there were no drugs in the toddler's system.
Dr Evans was asked by defence QC Edward Targowski: "You just don't know what the cause of death was?" and she replied: "That's correct."
Mr Targowski added: "There would have been a number of natural causes that could have led to Declan's death that because of decomposition you could not be clear about?"
Dr Evans replied: "That's correct... meningitis, inflammation of the heart, pancreatitis - the list is very long."
Dr Evans was then asked: "It could well be there was a rapid infection that caused rapid death," and she replied: "It's a possibility."
Mr Targowski asked: "You may be left with a dead child and you can't say how he died?"
Dr Evans replied: "With a child under 18 months it could come under sudden death syndrome."
Mr Targowski then added: "There is a part of medicine that recognises this happens?" and she said: "That's right."
Dr Evan was then asked: "It is possible that a mother could put a healthy baby down to sleep and wake up and find the child has died?"
She replied: "In theory it is possible."
Mr Targowski then said: "In practice as well. It does happen," and Dr Evans said: "Yes."
Ms Hainey, is accused of assaulting, wilfully ill-treating and neglecting her son Declan over a 19-month period between 1 September 2008 and 30 March last year.
The Crown has charged her with either murdering her son or alternatively of neglecting him by failing to provide medical care for him whereby his physical and psychological development were impaired.
It is alleged that she left her son alone and unattended in the house for excessive periods of time, left him in wet and soiled nappies for excessive periods of time, caused him to be exposed to heroin and amphetamine, caused him to ingest these drugs and failed to provide medical aid and care for him.
The Crown also alleges that Ms Hainey pretended that Declan was alive in an attempt to defeat the ends of justice between 1 July 2009 and 31 March 2010.
She is also accused of possessing heroin and supplying heroin to Greg Irving in Renfrew, on various occasions between 25 December 2009 and 31 March last year.
She denies all the charges against her.
The trial before Lord Woolman continues.
At 02:36:18 in BusinessFast food chain McDonald's has suspended sale of chicken nuggets and some other products in Hong Kong.
At 02:30:32 in HeadlinesAt least two Palestinians have been killed in the West Bank during protests against Israel's military campaign in Gaza, officials say.
At 02:20:04 in HeadlinesSub-Saharan Africa's agricultural sector needs to harvest the fruits of biotechnology in order to establish sustainable development, says a report.
At 02:19:11 in HeadlinesAll dinosaurs were covered with feathers or had the potential to grow feathers, a study suggests.
At 02:17:53 in HeadlinesNew research suggests the global decline in wildlife is connected to an increase in human trafficking and child slavery.
At 02:15:20 in HeadlinesA federal judge in Mexico has charged six employees of a children's home raided by police last week.
At 02:14:42 in HealthFree schools for children with autism are gradually being setup in the UK by community groups, with another one due to open in Easter 2015. But in the 1970s, parents in Sunderland clubbed together to create what they saw as a real need back in a time when autism wasn't such a well-known disability.
At 02:05:16 in EntertainmentProtest movements, from the Suffragettes to Occupy, have produced their own unique items designed to challenge the status quo. And for the first time these "disobedient objects" have been brought together in an exhibition at London's Victoria & Albert museum.
At 02:02:13 in HeadlinesAn American reporter for the Washington Post and his wife appear to have been detained in Tehran, the newspaper said.
At 01:48:38 in HeadlinesOn 18 September voters will go to the polls to decide whether Scotland should become an independent country. Only those registered to vote in Scotland will have a say. Here are some glittering icons in the Scottish firmament that won't.
Harvard CitationBBC News, 2011. Kimberley Hainey trial: Toddler death reason 'unclear' [Online] (Updated 23rd Nov 2011)
Available at: http://www.ukwirednews.com/news/204759/Kimberley-Hainey-trial-Toddler-death-reason-unclear [Accessed 25th Jul 2014]
News In Other Categories
Fast food chain McDonald's has suspended sale of chicken nuggets and some other products in Hong Kong.
A council has said any business which feels it has a "legitimate claim" can seek compensation over delayed upgrade works in Dumfries town centre.
The giant marionettes of French street theatre company Royal de Luxe are heading back to the streets of Liverpool to help mark the World War One centenary. But why does its eccentric director favour this UK city over others?
Dozens of schools across Scotland are delaying the introduction of new Highers in popular school subjects, according to BBC Scotland research.
A leading football coach, who believes in "nurturing" children as young as two, has been invited to tell the Football Association how to develop a successful England national side.
"This is our concern. When it comes to raising cattle it's our job, when you're born you see your father doing it, it represents everything to us."