Anti-terror stop-and-search powers need 'safeguards'
Published: 15th Jun 2011 20:04:25
Extra safeguards are needed to ensure counter-terrorism measures do not breach human rights laws, a government report has said.
The government modified the police's ability to stop and search people without grounds for suspicion after it was ruled illegal.
The home secretary now has to authorise a search but only if it is suspected that an act of terrorism could occur.
But the Joint Committee on Human Rights (JCHR) said the changes were too broad.
MPs and peers on the committee said the changes lacked adequate safeguards and did not go far enough to ease concerns raised originally by the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR).
It said police should have to ask a judge to authorise the power before it was used.
The changes introduced by Home Secretary Theresa May in March state that an assistant chief constable must sign the order off before it is then authorised by the home secretary.
It must then be used within 48 hours and cannot last longer than 14 days.
But the JCHR report said the stop-and-search order "in its current form does not go far enough to remove the incompatibility identified by [ECHR] and therefore risks giving rise to further breaches of convention rights".
Arbitrary stop-and-search powers allow the state to confront an individual in the street, without cause, and demand their papers - it's wrong”
JCHR said the officer authorising the use of stop and search must "have a reasonable basis for his or her belief as to the necessity of the authorisation and to provide an explanation of those reasons".
Authorisations should not be renewed unless there was "new or additional information or a fresh assessment of the original intelligence that the threat remains immediate and credible", they added.
JCHR chairman Dr Hywel Francis said the changes to stop-and-search powers must not breach the right to privacy in the same way as the powers previously did.
"We welcome the restrictions placed on the power by the government, but we believe it needs to be more tightly circumscribed, and it needs tougher legal safeguards if further breaches of human rights are to be avoided," he said.
"We also think that the government should provide more information about why this power needs to be introduced so urgently, so that the issue can be given proper parliamentary scrutiny."
The ECHR ruling in January last year came in a case brought by two Londoners who were stopped and questioned by police near an arms fair in the city in 2003.
The court said Kevin Gillan and Pennie Quinton's right to respect for a private and family life was violated.
And after the failed bomb attack against the Tiger Tiger nightclub in London's Haymarket in 2007, anti-terrorism chiefs ordered an escalation in the use of Section 44 stop-and-search powers.
That resulted in more than 250,000 people being searched in 2008-09 - the highest number on record and more than twice the level of the previous year.
But after a public outcry over the use of searches, which disproportionately affect minority groups, Metropolitan Police Commissioner Sir Paul Stephenson ordered them to be scaled back.
Daniel Hamilton, director of the Big Brother Watch campaign group, said: "While we welcome the conclusions [of JCHR] they could have gone much further.
"Rather than a genuine counter-terrorism and crime-fighting tool, stop and search has been a way of bullying and hassling our increasingly abject population.
"We have to decide what kind of society we want to live in. Arbitrary stop and search powers allow the state to confront an individual in the street, without cause, and demand their papers. It's wrong."
Corinna Ferguson, the lawyer from civil rights group Liberty who took the case on behalf of Mr Gillan and Ms Quinton, said the government "had to tighten the law" on stop and search.
"Unless Parliament addresses this, minority communities will continue to feel unjustly targeted and understandably resentful," she added.
At 19:39:42 in EnglandThe family of a man who died, despite seven 999 calls for an ambulance, said he was failed in his "moment of need".
At 19:38:42 in SportNetherlands keeper Michel Vorm believes Louis van Gaal would be the ideal choice as Manchester United manager.
At 19:32:11 in EnglandHeathrow Airport is gearing towards the opening of its new Terminal 2 by unveiling Europe's largest privately funded sculpture.
At 19:27:52 in EnglandThe death of a 10-year-old boy who was hit by a car as he crossed the road outside his house was accidental, an inquest has heard.
At 19:13:07 in PoliticsPrivate parking firms paid more than £6m to the DVLA for the names and addresses of drivers in the past year - an increase of 28%, figures suggest.
At 19:12:17 in EnglandPoppies have been planted as part of a social media campaign to mark the First World War in Jersey.
At 19:11:22 in WalesGriff Rhys Jones has withdrawn from becoming Cardiff University's new chancellor just two weeks after an embarrassing debacle which saw his appointment halted at the last minute.
At 19:04:14 in EnglandA theatre company is hoping to have set a new world record by performing an abridged version of Shakespeare's works at more than 37,000ft (11,278m).
At 18:56:33 in WorldThe Iron Curtain fell 25 years ago, but it seems that nobody told the deer.
At 18:54:46 in EnglandA council is expanding the size of graves to accommodate obese people - and could charge extra for larger people to be buried in them.
Harvard CitationBBC News, 2011. Anti-terror stop-and-search powers need 'safeguards' [Online] (Updated 15th Jun 2011)
Available at: http://www.ukwirednews.com/news/162466/Anti-terror-stop-and-search-powers-need-safeguards [Accessed 23rd Apr 2014]
News In Other Categories
A home security company is creating 230 jobs by expanding its operations in the Republic of Ireland.
The family of a man who died, despite seven 999 calls for an ambulance, said he was failed in his "moment of need".
The cost of drugs is in the headlines following the decision by NHS watchdog NICE that a new cancer treatment should not be funded.
Mexican writer and journalist Elena Poniatowska has received the most important award for literature in the Spanish language, the Cervantes prize.
Tesco's internet service has been hit by two separate problems that coincided, leaving some of its customers irate.
Portugal's chances of exiting its three-year bailout programme rose after the sale of 10-year government debt fell sharply to a record low 3.57%.