Labour's Harriet Harman demands media regulation
Published: 28th Oct 2012 11:33:48
Self-regulation of the media has "failed" and politicians must act to ensure "business as usual" is not an option, Harriet Harman has said.
Labour's deputy leader told BBC One's Andrew Marr Show politicians of all parties should unite to change the law to ensure a "truly independent" body is established to look at complaints.
The Leveson Inquiry on press standards is deciding its recommendations.
Opponents of statutory regulation say it would undermine freedom of speech.
The Leveson Inquiry, led by Lord Justice Leveson, was set up after allegations of widespread wrongdoing by the press, including the hacking of missing schoolgirl Milly Dowler's mobile phone.
It heard from politicians, celebrities, media figures, police and others over an eight-month period.
The inquiry is due to publish a report by the end of 2012 in which it will make recommendations on the future regulation of the press and conduct between the press, politicians and police.
Prime Minister David Cameron has committed himself to implementing these.
But, in recent weeks, campaigners for a statutory system of regulation, including the actor Hugh Grant, have voiced concern that this might not happen.
Speaking on BBC One's Andrew Marr Show, Ms Harman said: "I don't think self-regulation of the media should be given another chance. It's absolutely clear Leveson has given a great many revelations...
"It's clear that business as usual has nothing to obtain. The status quo has failed. There's not a proper press complaints system that ensures, where the press gets it wrong, the individual can complain and that will be looked at."
We should be very, very, very reluctant to take on legislation”
She added: "Self-regulation is business as usual. That's what has failed."
But Ms Harman insisted press freedom had to be maintained within the new framework of regulation, with censorship avoided, saying: "We ought to be clear that there can be no prior restraint."
She said: "We don't want any obstruction on press freedom... I have always argued for press freedom.
"We may need a statute to underline a truly independent press freedom."
She added: "There's every possibility of getting a cross-party agreement. This should not be a political football... We don't want politicians settle scores against the press who have been bruising them... The status quo is not acceptable."
But Communities Secretary Eric Pickles told Sky News: "I think it is really massively important to ensure we have freedom of press in this country."
He added: "I think it was Thomas Jefferson who said that for a free society to operate, then the 'river of a free press' had to 'flow without restriction'.
"I think, given that the press are looking towards finding ways, the end result of offering a good way that people who have a legitimate complaint can find recourse, then that is right.
"We should be very, very, very reluctant to take on legislation. It's a balance and my view is that we should always balance in favour of a free press."
Earlier this month Mr Cameron said he did not want "heavy-handed state intervention", adding: "We have got to have a free press."
And Conservative London Mayor Boris Johnson said the "free, dynamic, irreverent and independent media that we have" was "one of the glories of this country".
The Leveson Inquiry was set up to examine the culture, practice and ethics of the press, with the first stage examining relationships the press has with public, politicians and police.
A second part of the inquiry, looking into the extent of unlawful or improper conduct within News International and other newspaper media organisations, will not get under way until police investigations are concluded.
At 00:46:27 in WorldGifts and payments to US doctors from drug firms are seen by some as encouraging unnecessary prescriptions. Do such transfers make any difference and will President Obama's healthcare reform help, by forcing companies to disclose them?
At 00:31:46 in ScotlandDid business expert Lord Digby Jones bite off more than he could chew when he tried to help out a Hawick textile factory?
At 00:29:23 in ScotlandA new exhibition explores the impact of of World War One on thousands of Scots, both in service and back home.
At 00:25:52 in ScotlandThe recent decline in shopper numbers in Scotland has slowed significantly, according to figures released by retailers.
At 00:22:14 in ScotlandThe funeral of a 12-year-old girl who died after a wall fell on her at an Edinburgh school is due to be held later.
At 00:20:50 in ScotlandHe's the Scot credited with helping to establish America's national parks. Now, more than a century later, John Muir is to be honoured at the opening of a long distance path which bears his name.
At 00:20:30 in WorldThe world's largest democratic event, with over 800 million eligible voters, is under way.
At 00:17:43 in ScotlandScotland's economic performance has returned to pre-recession levels, according to a report.
At 00:02:42 in BusinessThe world is addicted to hydrocarbons, and it's easy to see why - cheap, plentiful and easy to mine, they represent an abundant energy source to fuel industrial development the world over.
At 00:02:32 in BusinessThe idea struck Rajiv Singh during a business trip to Germany, when a man arrived with a document from an office on the other side of town.
Harvard CitationBBC News, 2012. Labour's Harriet Harman demands media regulation [Online] (Updated 28th Oct 2012)
Available at: http://www.ukwirednews.com/news/1460521/Labours-Harriet-Harman-demands-media-regulation [Accessed 17th Apr 2014]
News In Other Categories
The world is addicted to hydrocarbons, and it's easy to see why - cheap, plentiful and easy to mine, they represent an abundant energy source to fuel industrial development the world over.
Scotland's economic performance has returned to pre-recession levels, according to a report.
Men prefer to watch film adaptations of books than read the original novel, according to a new study, which found the opposite is true for women.
The man cleared of killing PC Keith Blakelock has said he would feel "angry and disappointed at the system" if he was a member of the police officer's family.
As Google continues to stoke excitement for its Glass smart-eyewear, a Japanese researcher has developed a radical alternative.