Amish hair-cutting trial goes to Ohio jury
Published: 13th Sep 2012 23:52:31
An Ohio jury has begun deliberating in the case of 16 Amish people accused of hate crime after they cut the hair and beards of rivals.
Prosecutors say religious differences motivated the attacks by members of a breakaway group led by Samuel Mullet; uncut hair is an Amish symbol of faith.
Defence lawyers acknowledge the hair cutting took place, but say the hate-crime charges are excessive.
The six women and 10 men have pleaded not guilty.
The accused face up to life in prison if convicted.
Jurors ended their first day of deliberations without a verdict on Thursday at the US district court in Cleveland.
During the trial, prosecutors argued that the attacks were caused by disputes between Mr Mullet and the leaders of another Amish group, and that cutting their hair had "religiously degraded them".
They argue that Mr Mullet orchestrated the attacks, even if he was not present.
After every incident, the suspects returned to Mr Mullet's home, once giving him a paper bag stuffed with hair, prosecutor Kristy Parker said.
"None of the terror that was unleashed on the victims last fall would have happened without Sam Mullet," she said.
All of the victims were people who had a dispute with Mr Mullet over his religious practices and his authoritarian rule over the settlement he founded, she said.
Defence lawyers argued that the attacks were the result of family or financial disputes.
"Use common sense," defence lawyer Neal Atway told jurors. "What happened was offensive, but what crime was committed?"
Mr Mullet told the Associated Press in October that he did not order the attacks, but did not stop his sons and others in his group from carrying them out.
The Amish leader said in the interview that he had wanted to send a message that the others should be ashamed for the way they had treated his group.
Many Amish believe that the Bible instructs women to wear their hair long and for men to stop shaving after marriage.
Ohio has an Amish population of about 61,000 - second only to Pennsylvania.
Jefferson County Sheriff Fred Abdalla told journalists that Amish communities in the area had been left terrified by the attacks.
Within the Amish community, punishments are often decided internally and crimes are rarely reported to the police. Some of the victims of the attacks had refused to press charges.
At 21:01:42 in SportIreland assistant coach Les Kiss says France's variety of attacking options offer a major threat to Irish hopes of winning the Six Nations title in Paris.
At 20:59:36 in HeadlinesQuebec Premier Pauline Marois has said an independent Quebec would have no borders or tolls for Canadians, as she campaigns ahead of a 7 April election.
At 20:43:05 in WorldA collection of the world's oldest masks, dating back to the dawn of civilisation, have gone on display at the Israel Museum in Jerusalem.
At 20:04:57 in ScotlandTwo students who died after a driver's car mounted a pavement and hit them would still be alive if he had told the truth, an inquiry has heard.
At 20:04:39 in HeadlinesRebekah Brooks has denied knowing that the News of the World hacked Milly Dowler's phone at the time of the schoolgirl's disappearance, the phone-hacking trial has heard.
At 19:59:30 in HeadlinesIsrael has expressed regret over the death of a Jordanian judge, who was shot by Israeli soldiers at the Allenby Bridge border crossing on Monday.
At 19:58:51 in EnglandA man who ran a scam operation selling counterfeit car parts on the internet has been jailed for 20 months.
At 19:43:53 in EnglandThe Conservative party in Derby has asked the police to probe allegations of electoral fraud in the city.
At 19:36:02 in SportIreland and Leinster flanker Sean O'Brien is set to miss the rest of the season after an infection complicated his recovery from shoulder surgery.
At 19:25:03 in WalesThe role of keeping Britain's estate agents in check is set to change in the next few weeks - with some powers handed over to a Welsh council.
Harvard CitationBBC News, 2012. Amish hair-cutting trial goes to Ohio jury [Online] (Updated 13th Sep 2012)
Available at: http://www.ukwirednews.com/news/1451846/Amish-hair-cutting-trial-goes-to-Ohio-jury [Accessed 11th Mar 2014]
News In Other Categories
Director Lynne Ramsay has settled a legal dispute with the producers of the film Jane Got a Gun, which she quit days before shooting began last year.
Italy's biggest bank, UniCredit, has reported a record annual loss of 14bn euros (£11.7bn; $19bn) and said it plans to cut 8,500 jobs.
The Welsh exams board WJEC has launched an internal review after concerns were raised over results for a new GCSE in English taken in January.
The role of keeping Britain's estate agents in check is set to change in the next few weeks - with some powers handed over to a Welsh council.
Two students who died after a driver's car mounted a pavement and hit them would still be alive if he had told the truth, an inquiry has heard.