Tory MPs urge George Osborne to curb rail fare rises
Published: 20th Aug 2012 11:28:02
Conservative MPs are calling on George Osborne to stop rail firms increasing commuter fares by up to 11% in England.
The increases, due to come in next January, follow a spike in the rate of inflation used to set ticket prices.
But commuter belt Tory MPs say the price rises, meant to fund rail improvements, will deter people from working and harm economic growth.
Labour accused the MPs of "hypocrisy" for failing to oppose the rises in a Commons vote earlier this year.
The Retail Prices Index (RPI) of inflation is used to calculate season ticket rises, with operators in England allowed to bring in an annual average increase of RPI plus 3%.
RPI unexpectedly surged to 3.2% in July, the month on which next year's rises are based.
This means season ticket prices in England are set to go up by an average of 6.2% in January.
If MPs in England are asked whether they're happy with a 6.2% train fare rise that will hit the pockets of their cash-strapped constituents, few are likely to say yes.
And a number of Tories in the London commuter belt have said they'll try and persuade the chancellor to halt the fare hike.
Since 2004, rail fares have risen at a rate of RPI + 1%. An increase to RPI + 3% was due to kick in this year but George Osborne deferred the rise in last year's autumn statement. Will he do it again?
There's certainly some political pressure on him. But I don't think this a subject the Treasury will reopen. The big investment in the railways has to be paid for at a time of squeezed public finances.
The chancellor could ask his complaining MPs what they'd prefer instead: a cut to investment, higher government borrowing or putting more of the cost onto taxpayers? For now, it's rail users who are taking the strain and that's not likely to change.
In addition, rail companies are allowed extra flexibility, so some fares can rise by as much as 11%, as long as this is balanced out with smaller increases elsewhere.
Mark Reckless, Tory MP for Rochester and Strood, in Kent, home to many commuters, told BBC Radio 4's Today programme this would end up costing some workers hundreds of pounds extra a year.
He said: "Many of my constituents have to get up at five or six o'clock in the morning to take the coach to London because they cannot afford the train.
"Others have been priced out entirely because they were spending almost all their take-home income paying for a season ticket just to get to jobs in London.
"That's counter-productive because we want to encourage people to work hard and provide for their families rather than stay at home on welfare."
Mr Reckless added: "These RPI linkages don't really make sense when wages are going up, if at all, far less than inflation... That just discourages work."
Last year, Chancellor George Osborne intervened to cap average season ticket rises to a rate of RPI plus 1%, after protests from passenger groups.
Tracey Crouch, Conservative MP for Chatham and Aylesford, Kent, wants a repeat of this next January.
She told the BBC: "Fare increases of RPI plus 3% are coming at a time when household budgets are incredibly hard-pressed.
"A lower increase would mean there is still the investment needed for improvements but at a more proportionate cost for commuters."
In the longer term we are determined to get rid of these above-inflation fare rises all together”
Last year Labour put forward a parliamentary motion to set a permanent cap on season ticket rises of RPI plus 1%, but this was defeated.
Shadow transport secretary Maria Eagle said: "It is complete hypocrisy for Tory and Liberal Democrat MPs to claim to their constituents that they oppose 11% rail fare rises when they failed to vote against them in Parliament.
"The government has put the wrong people first by caving in to pressure from the private train companies and allowing them to hike rail tickets by up to 11% every year for three years."
Rail minister Theresa Villiers has said the fare increases are necessary in the short-term to achieve the government's goal of bringing down the cost of running railways and making services less dependent on taxpayers.
"In the longer term we are determined to get rid of these above-inflation fare rises all together," she said.
The government also insists the improvement of services, such as electrification and better carriages, necessitates higher fare increases in the short term.
RPI has fallen consistently since September last year, when it peaked at 5.6%.
In June, it stood at 2.8%, and many analysts expected the rate to fall further in July, but it increased to 3.2%.
Fares in Scotland they will go up by RPI plus 1% next year. Wales has yet to set a figure. Northern Ireland's train fare increases are not directly linked to the rate of inflation.
At 15:57:53 in EnglandA new commissioner will be appointed to oversee schools in Birmingham.
At 15:55:01 in SportJos Buttler has replaced wicketkeeper Matt Prior in the England squad for the third Test against India.
At 15:53:45 in SportMansfield Town have signed midfielder Simon Heslop on a free transfer.
At 15:52:43 in ScotlandCampaigner Peter Tatchell has called on First Minister Alex Salmond to condemn homophobia in some Commonwealth countries ahead of the Glasgow Games.
At 15:52:43 in HeadlinesFive children and an adult have been killed in a minibus crash near the French city of Troyes, south-east of Paris.
At 15:47:53 in EnglandAn autograph book signed by more than 100 World War One servicemen while they were patients in Cambridge has been donated to a hospital archive.
At 15:41:16 in EnglandA school that barred a girl from a trip to reward good attendance after she took a day off for her mother's funeral has blamed a computer for the blunder.
At 15:36:35 in SportEngland pace bowler James Anderson will face a hearing on 1 August after his alleged clash with India all-rounder Ravindra Jadeja during the first Test.
At 15:35:02 in EnglandA museum in Somerset is appealing for help in finding information about a World War One soldier, who is the subject of a 92-year-old bronze statue.
At 15:33:26 in EnglandNewcastle United paid tribute to the two fans who died in last week's plane crash in Ukraine, in their first match since the disaster.
Harvard CitationBBC News, 2012. Tory MPs urge George Osborne to curb rail fare rises [Online] (Updated 20th Aug 2012)
Available at: http://www.ukwirednews.com/news/1447114/Tory-MPs-urge-George-Osborne-to-curb-rail-fare-rises [Accessed 22nd Jul 2014]
News In Other Categories
A leading YouTube entrepreneur is facing legal action for alleged copyright infringement in her videos.
Five children and an adult have been killed in a minibus crash near the French city of Troyes, south-east of Paris.
A giant Welsh cake baked in a Gwynedd town has been confirmed as the largest ever made.
A new commissioner will be appointed to oversee schools in Birmingham.
Hundreds of young footballers from all over the UK and Ireland are in Londonderry this week for the Foyle Cup.
The creation of babies using sperm and eggs from three people has moved a step closer in the UK.