'Scandalising court' under review
Published: 10th Aug 2012 03:56:14
The ancient offence of scandalising the court is to be reviewed to see if it is still necessary.
The offence is a form of contempt of court, but has not been successfully prosecuted since 1931.
It is committed by publishing anything that ridicules the judiciary to the extent that it is likely to bring the administration of justice into disrepute.
The Law Commission is consulting on the law in England and Wales.
Examples of the offence include being extremely offensive to a judge, or accusing him of corruption.
It is also know as scandalising judges while in Scotland it is called "murmuring judges".
In the leading case, from 1900, a journalist was found guilty for describing a judge as an "impudent little man in horsehair, a microcosm of conceit and empty-headedness".
But the law is vague, and it is questionable whether it is compatible with the right to freedom of expression, and the European Convention on Human Rights.
There was also controversy surrounding the issue of whether there was any justification for retaining such an offence in a well-established democracy, the Law Commission said.
The consultation opens on Friday and closes on 10 October.
In May this year, former Northern Ireland secretary Peter Hain was accused of the offence after criticising a Belfast judge in his memoirs. However, the charge was dropped after he wrote to Northern Ireland Attorney General John Larkin clarifying the remarks.
At 12:55:33 in SportCoach Bobby Crutchley says Tim Whiteman has added an air of invincibility to the England squad for their Four Nations tournament in Glasgow.
At 12:50:28 in SportSt Johnstone striker Stevie May plans to open contract talks with the Perth club before the end of the season.
At 12:48:18 in SportTeam Sky will be without Great Britain's Sir Bradley Wiggins and Chris Froome for next month's Giro d'Italia, which starts in Belfast.
At 12:47:19 in ScotlandTwo men who admitted setting fire to a stolen car in an Aberdeenshire supermarket car park while people were still sitting inside have been told to carry out unpaid work.
At 12:47:14 in EnglandA woman in her 70s has been seriously injured after a BMW car crashed into her home in Essex.
At 12:41:30 in EnglandA detective sergeant, who was wrongly convicted of rape, has been suspended, despite an order to reinstate him.
At 12:40:59 in EnglandCoronation Street actress Barbara Knox has pleaded not guilty to drinking and driving.
At 12:38:34 in ScotlandPolice are investigating after a "large quantity" of bees were stolen from a Perthshire farm.
At 12:38:01 in SportGoodwood golfer Harry Callow says he was inspired to take up the sport after watching the film Happy Gilmore.
At 12:36:19 in WalesMore than 1,500 people in Wales have been caught not wearing seatbelts during a two-week campaign.
Harvard CitationBBC News, 2012. 'Scandalising court' under review [Online] (Updated 10th Aug 2012)
Available at: http://www.ukwirednews.com/news/1445504/Scandalising-court-under-review [Accessed 24th Apr 2014]
News In Other Categories
A woman in her 70s has been seriously injured after a BMW car crashed into her home in Essex.
Shots have been fired at a house in west Belfast in an incident being treated as a hate crime by police.
More than 1,500 people in Wales have been caught not wearing seatbelts during a two-week campaign.
Two men who admitted setting fire to a stolen car in an Aberdeenshire supermarket car park while people were still sitting inside have been told to carry out unpaid work.
Supporters of Scottish independence have questioned why the BBC has not resigned from the CBI over the business group's referendum stance.
Hospital admissions for dog bites are three times as high in the most deprived areas of England as in the least, official figures show.