BBC should not hand over Duggan shooting footage - judge
Published: 9th Aug 2012 11:45:17
A judge has said the BBC does not have to give the Metropolitan Police unbroadcast footage of the aftermath of the shooting of Mark Duggan.
The shooting sparked rioting in Tottenham, north London, last August, which later spread across the capital and to other parts of England.
Police applied for the footage as part of their probe into Kevin Hutchinson-Foster, who is accused of supplying Mr Duggan with a gun, something he denies.
The BBC had argued it was not relevant.
Judge David Radford, at Snaresbrook Crown Court, said he was not satisfied the material had substantial value to the case.
The broadcaster welcomed the ruling, saying it upheld important journalistic principles.
A BBC spokeswoman said: "On this occasion we opposed the court order because on the evidence provided by the police we were not satisfied the material was relevant to their investigation."
Mr Hutchinson-Foster, 29, was charged with possession of a firearm after allegedly assaulting a man in a hair salon in Hackney on 29 July last year.
Police believe the weapon used could be the same gun found at the shooting of 29-year-old Mr Duggan, who was shot when his taxi was stopped by armed police officers investigating gun crime on 4 August last year.
Mr Hutchinson-Foster's trial is due to begin next month.
Last month, the judge ruled that seven police officers could give evidence anonymously at Mr Hutchinson-Foster's trial. The judge said he made the order to prevent them from coming to harm.
A service was held to mark the death of Mr Duggan on Sunday, a year on from his death.
The Independent Police Complaints Commission is compiling a report that will be passed to a coroner in the autumn.
An inquest into the death of the father-of-four is due to take place in January but there is a possibility that some evidence about police operations will need to be heard in secret, which would mean that a special type of public inquiry would need to be held instead.
At 01:45:28 in PoliticsTwo former cabinet ministers have called for further scrutiny of the proposed appointment of the new House of Commons clerk amid an ongoing row.
At 01:05:44 in HeadlinesInfo
At 01:05:14 in HeadlinesThe small Northumberland town of Haltwhistle, close to Hadrian's Wall, has created a tourism industry around its claim to be at the centre of Britain. But what would Scottish independence mean for the town's future?
At 01:05:13 in WorldUN's human rights chief Navi Pillay has strongly criticised the UN Security Council for its failure to prevent conflicts around the world.
At 01:03:38 in HeadlinesIn the late 19th Century, thousands came to watch one of the most gruelling events in sporting history. And the man behind it all was the great-great-grandfather of David Cameron's wife Samantha.
At 01:02:54 in HeadlinesThere's a stereotypical image of the kind of men who go to prostitutes. But how do they explain paying for sex?
At 00:57:40 in WorldIn our series of letters from African journalists, Ghanaian writer Elizabeth Ohene, a former government minister and member of the opposition, considers how to take advantage of a crisis.
At 00:53:36 in WorldPolitical analyst Tobias Basuki likes to tell a story about Indonesian President-elect Joko Widodo that has perhaps been embellished over the years but shows why so many people have such high hopes for the country's next leader.
At 00:48:28 in HeadlinesThe bodies of 20 Malaysian victims of Flight MH17 that crashed in Ukraine in July are due to arrive in Kuala Lumpur, as the nation holds a day of mourning.
At 00:44:24 in HeadlinesBaby corals and fish can smell the difference between good and bad reefs, according to a study based in Fiji.
Harvard CitationBBC News, 2012. BBC should not hand over Duggan shooting footage - judge [Online] (Updated 9th Aug 2012)
Available at: http://www.ukwirednews.com/news/1445348/BBC-should-not-hand-over-Duggan-shooting-footage-judge [Accessed 22nd Aug 2014]
News In Other Categories
Two teenagers have been charged with the murder of 19-year-old Charlie Burns in Hackney, east London.
A six-year-old girl who is believed to have choked while on holiday with her family in Gwynedd has been named as Jasmine Lapsley.
Argentina's plan to exit its debt default by asking investors holding defaulted bonds to swap them for new locally issued debt has been ruled "illegal" by a US court.
BBC journalists "acted appropriately" in coverage of the police search of Sir Cliff Richard's home, director general Tony Hall has said.
A security alert is underway at Fanad Drive in the Creggan area of Londonderry, following the hijacking of a delivery van in the city.