Samsung rebuked by patent judge in trial against Apple
Published: 3rd Aug 2012 21:42:58
A judge has rebuked Samsung after it sent a press release at the start of a patent trial involving the South Korean tech firm and Apple.
Judge Lucy Koh said there had been "a wilful attempt to propagate... evidence they knew had been excluded" from the case.
She added there had been a risk "of a jury taint".
However, she rejected Apple's request that she rule some of its patents valid in order to punish Samsung.
Samsung's PR agency emailed a nine-page presentation to reporters on Tuesday.
It contained evidence that Apple had based one of its handset prototypes on what it thought a Sony-based iPhone might look like. The aim was to undermine its right to a design patent.
It also showed a Samsung handset, which the firm suggested showed it had been working on iPhone-like design before Apple's device had been unveiled.
The judge blocked the details because she said the South Korean firm had tried to introduce them too late into the legal process.
But a statement from Samsung, included in its press release, said: "Fundamental fairness requires that the jury decide the case based on all the evidence."
Apple subsequently claimed it had been an attempt to "pollute the jury".
Samsung denied this, but Judge Koh said "consequences" might be appropriate after the trial ended.
But she added that for now she would "not let any theatrics or any sideshow distract us from what we are here to do".
She did, however, question each of the jurors to confirm they had not read any of the news articles containing the banned information.
The case centres on Apple's allegation that Samsung infringed seven of its patents and owes it $2.5bn (£1.6bn) in damages, and the South Korean firm's counter-claim that its rival has breached five of its intellectual properties and should be paying it an unspecified share of its mobile device revenues.
The jury is expected to hear a total of four weeks of evidence.
But the judge has also voiced her frustration at delays caused by the number of objections each side was making about the other.
As a result she has now ruled that time taken to lodge each objection will be deducted from each side's time as a disincentive.
Apple's vice president of worldwide marketing, Philip Schiller, was the first witness to testify after the trial resumed on Friday.
He attributed the iPad's success to the fact that "customers value beautiful products and that they can identify with the company that makes them", according to a transcript provided by Forbes magazine.
His statement is an attempt to demonstrate the value of Apple's design patents and suggest Samsung had caused it harm by infringing them.
Speaking on the first day of the trial, Mr Schiller told the jury: "I was pretty shocked at the appearance of the Galaxy S phone and the extent it appeared to copy Apple products."
He claimed that when he saw Samsung's Galaxy Tab, "I thought they've done it again, they're just going to copy our whole product line."
The Galaxy Tab maker denies the charge, saying its rival's patent "shows little more than a blank rectangle" and it would go against legal precedent to allow it to "monopolise the shape of an article".
At 05:28:48 in EnglandThe Conservatives have said they will not subsidise new onshore wind farms if they win the 2015 general election.
At 04:37:25 in EnglandA man impaled in the neck by an industrial drill in a "freak accident" has been taken to hospital.
At 04:26:59 in HealthThe number of older people in England needing care will "outstrip" the number of family members able to provide it by 2017, a think tank has warned.
At 04:21:05 in HeadlinesUS President Barack Obama is meeting Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe for talks on regional security and trade, on the first full day of his Asia tour.
At 04:02:52 in HeadlinesThe UN Secretary General has accused all parties in Syria's civil war of "flagrant violations" of international law over the delivery of aid.
At 04:00:21 in HeadlinesCanada says it will phase out the type of rail tankers involved in a deadly train derailment last July.
At 03:49:53 in HeadlinesThe oldest former player with Major League Baseball, Conrado "Connie" Marrero, has died in at home in Havana at the age of 102.
At 03:28:13 in WorldIndians are voting in the sixth phase of a marathon general election in which the governing Congress party is fighting the main opposition BJP.
At 03:13:22 in ScotlandThe last avalanche forecast of the latest Sportscotland Avalanche Information Service (SAIS) season has been published.
At 03:06:05 in ScotlandWhen Nicola Sturgeon joined the SNP, pursuing a career in politics was not her agenda.
Harvard CitationBBC News, 2012. Samsung rebuked by patent judge in trial against Apple [Online] (Updated 3rd Aug 2012)
Available at: http://www.ukwirednews.com/news/1444436/Samsung-rebuked-by-patent-judge-in-trial-against-Apple [Accessed 24th Apr 2014]
News In Other Categories
Eighteen-time US Olympic swimming champion Michael Phelps says concerns about weight gain were behind his decision to return to the sport.
The Conservatives have said they will not subsidise new onshore wind farms if they win the 2015 general election.
The number of older people in England needing care will "outstrip" the number of family members able to provide it by 2017, a think tank has warned.
The Irish education minister has proposed a radical shake-up of the further education sector.
Griff Rhys Jones has withdrawn from becoming Cardiff University's new chancellor just two weeks after an embarrassing debacle which saw his appointment halted at the last minute.
Cult comic character Frank Sidebottom has inspired a film starring Michael Fassbender, while a documentary and biography are also in the works. Four years after his creator Chris Sievey died, why is Frank's legend growing and who was the man behind the mask?