Vulnerable children 'at risk' in new protection system
Published: 28th Jul 2012 00:11:11
Some of England's most vulnerable children may lose out under planned changes to the child protection system, a new campaign group has argued.
The government wants to cut bureaucracy and replace more than 700 pages of guidance with three short documents.
But the group Every Child In Need say the new rules are too vague and risk letting local authorities "do what they want when they want".
Organiser Steve Broach said the changes risked harming vulnerable children.
Mr Broach, a specialist children's rights barrister, told BBC News: "In a time of cuts to take away minimum standards to vulnerable children and to rely on individual local authorities to get it right every time on their own is dangerous and irresponsible."
The group is particularly concerned that the relaxing of the rules may lead to delays.
For example, the government proposes removing the requirement for local authorities to prepare an initial assessment of a child's needs within seven working days of a referral and a more detailed assessment within seven weeks.
Referrals can be from lawyers, schools, neighbours, the police or anyone else who raises concerns about a child's welfare or well-being.
The group fears that "many local authorities - cash-strapped following swingeing cuts to their budgets - are happy to take this lifeline which will mean less pressure to act quickly when a child in need comes to their attention".
It argues that, far from cutting bureaucracy, the changes will remove "an essential safety net for children when they are failed by their local authority".
The group also says the new rules are overly-focused on child protection and will ignore a much larger number of children who have significant needs but are not at immediate risk of abuse.
They give the examples of disabled children, homeless children or children who have been trafficked.
Mr Broach, of Doughty Street Chambers, said: "To focus solely on children who are already at risk of significant harm and ignore those with lower-level needs is going to result in an explosion of child protection cases down the line."
Campaign supporters, the National Deaf Children's Society, said it was concerned the changes would "make it harder for deaf children in England to get the social care support they need".
"These changes threaten to weaken vital protections and make a bad situation worse," it added.
The government's proposals follow a review last year which said social workers should be freed from bureaucracy.
In the wake of the death of Baby Peter in Haringey, north London, Education Secretary Michael Gove asked social policy expert Professor Eileen Munro to assess the child protection system in England.
Ministers have responded by announcing that three guidance documents, totalling 68 pages, will replace more than 700 pages of current guidance.
The new structure is currently being piloted by eight local authorities.
A Department for Education spokesman said: "There is nothing more important than protecting the welfare of vulnerable children, and this is precisely why we have cut burdensome red tape to let professionals get on with their jobs.
"Professor Munro's review of child protection recommended that we reduce unnecessary bureaucracy to free up professionals to give to right help to all vulnerable young people.
"We agree and that's why we are making these changes."
In July, a progress review for the government by the Childhood Wellbeing Research Centre found that social workers welcomed the new system and were able to do more family visits.
Critics have complained the researchers did not speak to any children or families involved.
At 22:44:04 in WorldWang Fang didn't work for the Shanghai Husi Food Company for long.
At 22:36:34 in SportCeltic will play Legia Warsaw in the third round of Champions League qualifying after the Polish side beat St Patrick's Athletic 5-0 for a 6-1 aggregate win.
At 22:32:56 in SportReal Madrid's Gareth Bale feels the club's £71m capture of James Rodriguez underlines La Liga's status as the best league in the world.
At 22:24:58 in EnglandA British teenager has paid tribute to her mother and aunt, who were killed by a man driving the wrong way down a US road.
At 21:50:01 in EnglandA 20-year-old man from Suffolk has been fined £200 after he was filmed swallowing two goldfish as part of a 'Neknominate' online dare.
At 21:44:03 in BusinessFacebook has announced a 138% rise in net income for the second quarter to $791m (£464m).
At 21:28:30 in SportWhen Glasgow secured the right to host the 2014 Commonwealth Games, organisers promised it would be the rebirth of the event and the best ever.
At 21:25:49 in WalesA Canadian IT services company is creating 25 jobs in Caerphilly.
At 21:20:01 in WalesRemains found hanging from a tree in thick undergrowth at a Gwynedd golf club were identified by DNA profiling as those of a Northamptonshire woman, an inquest has heard.
At 21:02:58 in HeadlinesThe trial of a suburban Detroit man charged with second-degree murder in the shooting death of an unarmed black woman on his porch has begun.
Harvard CitationBBC News, 2012. Vulnerable children 'at risk' in new protection system [Online] (Updated 28th Jul 2012)
Available at: http://www.ukwirednews.com/news/1443205/Vulnerable-children-at-risk-in-new-protection-system [Accessed 23rd Jul 2014]
News In Other Categories
Doctors in India have extracted 232 teeth from the mouth of a 17-year-old boy in a seven-hour operation.
Celtic will play Legia Warsaw in the third round of Champions League qualifying after the Polish side beat St Patrick's Athletic 5-0 for a 6-1 aggregate win.
The Conservative Party is privately discussing the future of one of its MPs - who was arrested and cautioned for common assault on his ex-partner, the BBC understands.
Last-minute preparations are underway for the 2014 Commonwealth Games opening ceremony at Celtic Park in Glasgow.
A British teenager has paid tribute to her mother and aunt, who were killed by a man driving the wrong way down a US road.
Facebook has announced a 138% rise in net income for the second quarter to $791m (£464m).