Academic defends NHS report after 'dodgy dossier' claim
Published: 10th Jul 2012 06:48:05
A report calling for controversial changes to NHS hospitals has been branded a "dodgy dossier" after emails between its academic author and senior Welsh government officials emerged.
Health economist Professor Marcus Longley asked civil servants for "killer facts" to support reforms.
He expressed concern the "evidence as presented does not seem to be as incisive as we might have hoped".
Prof Longley and the Welsh government insisted the report was independent.
The report makes a strong and valid case for change in the way our NHS operates and was compiled without bias or influence”
Ministers have repeatedly stated the report is an impartial academic work which cemented and underpinned their argument for major changes to the NHS.
Emails show Prof Longley asking the NHS Wales medical director Dr Chris Jones, who is also a senior Welsh government civil servant, for further evidence "to sharpen up the document and its impact in supporting the case for change".
In another email, Dr Jones asks Prof Longley to make his report "more positive if possible i.e describing a persuasive vision of how things could be better".
Prof Longley is a highly respected health economist and director of the Welsh Institute for Health and Social Care at the University of Glamorgan.
In February, the emails show him expressing concern to top Welsh government officials that he does not have enough data to prove services need to be overhauled.
He says: "As we've discussed, a crucial piece in the jigsaw is the argument 'we can't stay as we are: just look at outcomes'. So far, so elusive!"
In another email exchange with Prof Longley in January 2012, another senior civil servant offers to make new NHS performance data available to him, saying there is a "good bit on mortality for the first time e.g weekend effect".
When Professor Longley's report, called The Best Configuration of Hospital Services for Wales was released in May, Health Minister Lesley Griffiths said it was an "independent assessment of the evidence".
She said it "cemented and underpinned" the case for change, adding that Prof Longley had "approached the study from a completely independent position and drawn together the evidence as it is".
She told AMs: "This report constitutes strong evidence from a clinical perspective - not a political one."
Prof Longley's report warns that some services "will collapse" because of staff shortages if changes are not made.
All seven local health boards (LHBs) in Wales are in the final stages of preparing plans for a major reconfiguration of services, which are likely to be highly controversial when published over the coming months.
Prof Longley said: "The Case for Change document is an entirely independent piece of work carried out by myself in partnership with NHS Confederation Wales.
"The Welsh government is by definition the sole custodian of much of the data required in compiling this report, and any correspondence with them was to source this information.
"The report makes a strong and valid case for change in the way our NHS operates and was compiled without bias or influence."
Conservative shadow health minister Darren Millar said: "This evidence stinks. It shows that senior Welsh government officials, the Welsh NHS Confederation and Prof Longley connived together to produce a report with a pre-determined conclusion to pre-empt the unpopular reorganisation of health services across the country.
This evidence stinks”
"Prof Longley's report was far from the independent piece of academic research the minister claimed it to be - it was clearly a 'sexed up' 'dodgy dossier' and should be regarded as such."
Welsh Liberal Democrat leader Kirsty Williams said: "These email exchanges clearly contradict the health minister's statements that this case for change report was an 'independent assessment' and that it was 'impartial, based solely on the evidence'.
"This is an appalling insult to the many people in Wales who are rightfully concerned about the impending NHS reorganisation. How can we now have confidence in the Welsh Labour government's reorganisation process when they sex-up documents to suit their own needs?"
Plaid Cymru health spokeswoman Elin Jones said: "It is very clear that a conclusion was decided on up front and the correspondence illustrates a desperate search for the evidence to substantiate that.
"The report has lost any credibility and is certainly not independent."
Mrs Griffiths's spokesman said: "The Case for Change report produced by Professor Marcus Longley, was commissioned and owned by local health boards and the NHS Confederation.
"Welsh government officials responded to requests for statistical and other information from Professor Longley and the NHS Confederation."
He added: "The Welsh government did not seek to influence or amend the content of the report, as that was entirely a matter for the NHS Confederation and Professor Longley.
"This is another desperate attempt by opposition parties to destabilise a very important debate on the future of our NHS for narrow and cynical political purposes.
"The people of Wales have the choice of believing the evidence based research of an independent and respected academic, or more nonsense from an increasingly desperate opposition. It will be no contest."
In May, First Minister Carwyn Jones told AMs the report was commissioned by Confederation, adding: "It is not a government report."
Welsh NHS Confederation director Helen Birtwhistle said: "The report by the Welsh Institute for Health and Social Care was commissioned by the NHS in Wales to provide an independent overview of what the clinical evidence says about the best configuration for hospital services in Wales.
"LHBs felt it was critical that the public have access to clear and independent information to help them examine their forthcoming service plans.
"The Welsh NHS Confederation co-ordinated the publication of the final report, and associated communications activity, after its completion in April 2012."
Analysis: Hospital reform report
At 09:58:00 in EnglandA 69-year-old man has been arrested after a woman died at a house in Wiltshire.
At 09:49:06 in ScotlandA tower block in Edinburgh was evacuated on Friday night as bomb disposal crews investigated the discovery of "suspicious items".
At 09:38:13 in EnglandA giant bronze sculpture of a brewery dray horse will be paraded through the streets of Dorchester later.
At 09:18:06 in EnglandA man has been charged on suspicion of attempted murder after another man was injured in a shooting in Bournemouth.
At 09:06:47 in EnglandOne woman has died and seven people, including an 11-year-old boy, have been seriously injured in a three-vehicle crash in Lincolnshire.
At 08:51:38 in EnglandPoliticians should be paid according to how much responsibility they take on, Jersey's treasury minister said.
At 08:50:05 in BusinessTaxpayers' personal data could be shared with private firms under plans drawn up by Revenue & Customs (HMRC).
At 08:49:50 in EnglandAs a form of design, Brutalism has divided opinion for decades. In recent years many examples have been razed to the ground, with Northampton's Greyfriars bus station next in line. So why are some mourning the potential loss of an entire era of architecture?
At 08:48:34 in HeadlinesThe search for three missing Sherpa guides on Mount Everest has resumed after 13 were killed by an avalanche.
At 08:24:44 in WalesThe Welsh Rugby Union (WRU) is set to appoint its first woman board member in its 133 year history.
Harvard CitationBBC News, 2012. Academic defends NHS report after 'dodgy dossier' claim [Online] (Updated 10th Jul 2012)
Available at: http://www.ukwirednews.com/news/1439601/Academic-defends-NHS-report-after-dodgy-dossier-claim [Accessed 19th Apr 2014]
News In Other Categories
The Welsh Rugby Union (WRU) is set to appoint its first woman board member in its 133 year history.
The chair of the panel set up to advise the NHS and ministers on the governance of patient information has told the BBC the Care.data programme was mishandled.
Susanne du Toit won last year's BP Portrait Prize, one of the UK's most prestigious visual arts awards.
The Welsh Rugby Union (WRU) is set to appoint its first woman board member in its 133 year history.
A 69-year-old man has been arrested after a woman died at a house in Wiltshire.
With the doors to its brand new £1million training centre officially open, one of the UK's leading apprentice training providers, Bristol based S&B Automotive Academy, is showcasing its world-class facilities by launching a series of foreign student exchanges for the first time in its 41-year history. To get a flavour of what life is like as an apprentice in the UK, the Academy hosted 16 apprentice engineers and bus drivers from the G9 Automotive College in Hamburg, Germany, as part of a Europe-wide vocational training initiative called the ‘Leonardo Programme’ with support from the European Social Fund. In a reciprocal arrangement, S&B will be sending nine apprentices to Germany during February 2012 so that they can get an appreciation of life in the automotive industry on the Continent. A further three German exchange groups are being planned for next year. Designed to assist the development of vocational skills and training across Europe, including work placements for trainees, the Leonardo Programme has a budget of €1.75bn, which is helping to encourage UK organisations to work with their counterparts abroad. In what is expected to be another challenging year for employers in the UK automotive sector, S&B’s Chief Executive, Jon Winter, claims that the exchange initiative will bring many benefits to the Academy and its apprentices: “In a world of global automotive brands, it’s important for our learners to understand the international context of the industry they have chosen to make their career. This new exchange programme will enable apprentices and Academy staff alike to achieve a better understanding of the challenges and opportunities within the automotive arena in Europe. With the Academy’s influence also extending to the USA and Asia, there’s every possibility that this initiative could move further afield in the future.” Continued Winter: “The need for skilled technicians across the world is on the increase and we actively encourage our apprentices to look at broader horizons during their training. Many of them have already learned the phrase ‘Vorsprung durch Gelehrtheit’, quite simply, ‘Advancement through learning.” In the 2010/11 academic year, S&B doubled the number of successful Apprenticeships over the previous year with some 350 apprentices graduating from the Academy. At the same time, achievement levels reached an all-time high with an overall success rate of 85%. For those learners on the Advanced Apprenticeship three-year programme, success rates were even higher, at over 98%. PHOTO CAPTION: As part of their exchange visit, S&B Automotive Academy arranged for the German apprentices to visit Hampshire bus operator, Bluestar, at its Barton Park depot. The students are pictured with S&B’s Andy West (3rd right) and Steve Prewett, Bluestar’s Area Engineering Manager (2nd right). Ends http://www.sandbaa.com