Swansea murder trial mother Michelle Smith blames hospital
Published: 29th Jun 2012 17:11:16
A mother accused of poisoning her baby has told a jury how she cradled her for an hour in hospital after she died.
Michelle Smith, 34, from Swansea denies murdering six-week-old Amy Louise in 2007.
She is accused of giving the child a powerful adult painkiller but told the jury someone in a hospital must have administered it.
Mrs Smith broke down as she relived the last moments with her daughter, at Swansea Crown Court.
Giving evidence for the first time, she told the jury how she was allowed to hold Amy's body for an hour in hospital, where medics had battled to revive the child.
The infant had been rushed to Singleton Hospital where doctors had managed to find a "slight heartbeat".
I couldn't let her go. I was on the floor telling them they could not take her, she was my daughter”
Speaking in the witness stand on Friday, Mrs Smith said that, as her hopes were briefly raised, consultant paediatrician Ingo Scholler explained that if Amy survived she would be brain-damaged.
Moments later she and her husband Christopher were told it was "pointless" continuing efforts to save Amy and the couple were asked permission to turn off her life-support machine.
Dr Scholler then placed Amy's body in her arms as the machine was turned off and the baby was pronounced dead.
"Dr Scholler hugged us both and said he was sorry. He still could not tell us what happened because he did not know," Mrs Smith told the court.
"I couldn't let her go. I was on the floor telling them they could not take her, she was my daughter."
During her trial, the jury has heard that drug dihydrocodeine was discovered in Amy's blood when a post-mortem examination was carried out to determine the cause of death.
It also emerged that an earlier urine sample had tested positive for the same drug but the result was never passed to the baby's doctors.
Mrs Smith, from Morriston in the city, has also insisted she had not taken any medication during Amy's brief life.
Christopher Clee QC, prosecuting, cross examining Mrs Smith said: "You are not suggesting, are you, that Christopher Smith had something to do with this, are you?"
"No," Mrs Smith replied.
She also agreed that Gillian Davies, the health visitor, who saw Amy on the day she died, could also be excluded.
"So if it was not you it must have been someone else," Mr Clee said.
"Yes it was. In the hospitals," Mrs Smith answered.
"Either deliberately or accidentally," Mr Clee said.
"Yes," Mrs Smith replied.
Mr Clee said none of the several hospitals where Amy was taken had any record of ever "prescribing or administering" DHC to Amy.
Mrs Smith said: "I do not accept that," and went on to claim that while there was no record it did not mean it had not been done.
She also denies an alternative charge of causing or allowing the death of a child, and the trial continues.
At 08:00:54 in EnglandAbout 400 jobs are to be created across Teesside and North Yorkshire thanks to £30m of investment from Quorn Foods.
At 07:59:42 in Northern IrelandAn independent ambulance service has said lives are at risk after £10,000 worth of equipment was stolen from one of its vehicles in Londonderry.
At 07:57:44 in WorldThe South Korean school devastated by the loss of many of its students in a ferry disaster last week has started to hold classes again.
At 07:51:52 in EnglandPart of the M42 in the West Midlands has been closed after a lorry overturned, spilling diesel on to the motorway.
At 07:46:39 in WalesThe One Show's Alex Jones, Olympic athlete Iwan Thomas and tenor and Radio Wales presenter Wynne Evans are among the baton bearers for the Wales leg of the of the Commonwealth Games build up.
At 07:44:08 in SportFootball Association of Wales chief executive Jonathan Ford hopes the Uefa Super Cup will act as a platform in Cardiff's bid to be one of the host cities for Euro 2020.
At 07:38:26 in WorldThree foreigners have been shot dead by a security guard at a hospital in the Afghan capital, Kabul, officials say.
At 07:33:32 in BusinessSouth Korea's economy grew more than forecast in the first quarter, helped by a jump in construction and exports.
At 07:33:28 in SportTrainer Gary Lockett says talks have begun about a rematch between Enzo Maccarinelli and WBA light-heavyweight champion Jurgen Braehmer.
At 07:29:11 in EnglandPolice are continuing to question a 42-year-old woman suspected of murdering three of her children in south-west London.
Harvard CitationBBC News, 2012. Swansea murder trial mother Michelle Smith blames hospital [Online] (Updated 29th Jun 2012)
Available at: http://www.ukwirednews.com/news/1437771/Swansea-murder-trial-mother-Michelle-Smith-blames-hospital [Accessed 24th Apr 2014]
News In Other Categories
Cult comic character Frank Sidebottom has inspired a film starring Michael Fassbender, while a documentary and biography are also in the works. Four years after his creator Chris Sievey died, why is Frank's legend growing and who was the man behind the mask?
The One Show's Alex Jones, Olympic athlete Iwan Thomas and tenor and Radio Wales presenter Wynne Evans are among the baton bearers for the Wales leg of the of the Commonwealth Games build up.
About 400 jobs are to be created across Teesside and North Yorkshire thanks to £30m of investment from Quorn Foods.
Shares in Qualcomm, one of the world's biggest chipmakers, fell 5% in after hours trading as it issued a weaker than expected growth outlook.
Football Association of Wales chief executive Jonathan Ford hopes the Uefa Super Cup will act as a platform in Cardiff's bid to be one of the host cities for Euro 2020.
The South Korean school devastated by the loss of many of its students in a ferry disaster last week has started to hold classes again.