BBC's Arab Spring coverage 'impartial' but 'could have been fuller'
Published: 25th Jun 2012 18:06:13
The BBC's coverage of the Arab Spring was generally impartial but could have benefited from greater breadth and context, according to the BBC Trust.
It said the BBC should have done more to authenticate user-generated content (UGC), such as mobile phone footage taken by activists or bystanders.
The Trust praised "the considerable courage of journalists and technicians on the ground to bring stories to air".
Its report described the BBC's overall coverage as "remarkable".
Yet the report also said there could have been more extensive follow-up of stories in some countries, a fuller examination of the different voices of opposition, and a broader range of international reaction to the events.
The review was led by Edward Mortimer, a Middle East expert and former United Nations director of communications.
He praised the coverage of the 18 days of protests in Egypt leading to the fall of President Mubarak, the maintenance of a BBC presence on both sides of the conflict in Libya, and the coverage of the uprising in Tunisia.
But he expressed concern at the drop in the BBC's coverage of Egypt after President Mubarak's fall, and the delay in covering human rights abuses by rebel forces in Libya.
He also questioned the lack of coverage of Saudi Arabia, and the lack of a clear policy about the use of the word "regime" to describe governments that faced uprisings.
Mr Mortimer wrote that he was particularly impressed by "the skill and care the BBC applies to checking user-generated content" but said audiences should be given more information about this.
Analysis by Loughborough University found that in 74 per cent of UGC cases studied, the BBC failed to offer "caveats about authenticity or representativeness".
The report said more effort should be made to draw the attention of viewers and listeners to the BBC News website.
This "provides a significant amount of background material, yet no cross-reference was made to it in 97 per cent of BBC news items". A BBC news executive told the report's author he felt strongly that greater effort should be made to do this.
The Trust said it commissioned the review not because it felt the BBC's coverage of the Arab Spring was deficient, but because it showed "the importance and complexities of a group of fast-moving stories which are often extremely dangerous to cover on the ground".
The BBC said it was pleased to see the report's broad support for its coverage as a whole and the overall recognition of much "outstanding" and "remarkable" journalism.
At the same time, it continued, "we also had to make sure we were covering major stories happening simultaneously elsewhere".
At 21:53:18 in BusinessThe long holiday season is drawing to a close, with families across the UK counting the cost of trips at home and abroad.
At 21:48:53 in SportIndia eased to a 95-run victory over Middlesex at Lord's ahead of the one-day series against England next week.
At 21:48:00 in EnglandA gang who admitted ram-raiding a jewellery store to steal about £100,000 of jewellery and cash have been jailed.
At 21:26:28 in SportLate tries from Henry Slade and Matt Jess saw Exeter snatch a 22-21 win over Ulster in the friendly match between the sides at the Kingspan Stadium.
At 21:01:25 in EnglandA retired teacher from Cumbria was killed during a "dream trip" to the United States when a truck skidded into her train at a highway crossing in Nevada, an inquest has heard.
At 20:44:47 in EnglandA psychiatric nurse who exchanged "explicit messages and photographs" with a sex offender has avoided being struck off.
At 20:32:10 in EnglandA man who filmed his violent abuse of a woman has been convicted of six charges of rape.
At 20:30:19 in EnglandThe victim of a homophobic attack by two men has shared photos of her injuries in an attempt to find them.
At 20:21:28 in SportDan Greaves won his second major title of the summer as Great Britain claimed five more gold medals at the IPC Athletics European Championships.
At 19:54:47 in Northern IrelandA 25-year-old man has been taken to hospital after a suspected stabbing in north Belfast.
Harvard CitationBBC News, 2012. BBC's Arab Spring coverage 'impartial' but 'could have been fuller' [Online] (Updated 25th Jun 2012)
Available at: http://www.ukwirednews.com/news/1436814/BBCs-Arab-Spring-coverage-impartial-but-could-have-been-fuller [Accessed 22nd Aug 2014]
News In Other Categories
Ambridge is to get a dose of pop star royalty after it was revealed that pop duo Pet Shop Boys are to make a cameo appearance on Radio 4's The Archers.
The bosses of the BBC and South Yorkshire Police have been summoned to appear before MPs after a claim of a "cover-up" over a recent police raid on Sir Cliff Richard's Berkshire home.
A 91-year-old great-grandmother needed surgery after being bitten by a dog while walking home in Cardiff.
The brother of two killers has admitted attempting to murder a key witness who helped convict them.
The long holiday season is drawing to a close, with families across the UK counting the cost of trips at home and abroad.
The UK medicines watchdog is to review the safety of a clot-busting drug often used to treat strokes.