Nick Clegg blasts Michael Gove over scrap GCSE plan
Published: 21st Jun 2012 18:13:30
Deputy Prime Minister Nick Clegg has reacted angrily to Michael Gove's plan to scrap GCSEs in England saying they would create a "two-tier system".
Mr Clegg said the education secretary's announcement was "self-evidently not policy that has been discussed or agreed within the coalition".
The Daily Mail said Mr Gove wants to bring back a system similar to the O-Levels, with CSEs for less able pupils.
He later told MPs the current system was letting children down.
But Mr Clegg, who is at an UN conference on sustainable development in Brazil, said: "I am not in favour of anything that would lead to a two-tier system where children at quite a young age are somehow cast on a scrap heap."
Asked if Mr Gove was wrong to do what he was doing, Mr Clegg said: "Mr Gove is entirely entitled to come up with proposals and then if he wants to we can discuss them within the government.
"It's really important we have an exam system that's fit for the future, and doesn't just hark back to the past. That it really pushes all children across the whole school system and doesn't just cater for a small number of children".
If the plan goes ahead, students would begin studying what the leaked document says will be "tougher" O-level style exams in English, maths and the sciences from September 2014. They would take their exams in 2016.
Less academic pupils would sit a different "more straightforward" exam, like the old CSE.
The ideas, if introduced, would amount to the biggest change to the exams system for a generation.
Following the angry reaction from Lib Dems, Downing Street stressed that the plans were "not there yet" and were going to be put out for consultation.
But a senior Liberal Democrat source said the plan would be a "huge upheaval for very modest gains".
This leak seems to have taken officials at the Department for Education by surprise.
The timing is certainly not good, with tens of thousands of teenagers in the final days of their GCSE and A-level exams catching headlines suggesting the government does not think their exams are tough enough.
If ministers decide to go ahead with the proposals and the time-scale given, they cannot afford to hang around. The design and approval of the new exams will take time and that will come after the consultation planned for the autumn.
In Wales and Northern Ireland, the devolved governments will need to decide whether to stay in step with the proposed changes. They could continue to let their schools choose GCSE qualifications from the exam boards, which are private companies.
The source continued: "The main problem we have with this is it looks like it sets far too low an aspiration for our young people.
"Nick Clegg and the Lib Dems do not want to return to the divisions we saw in the 1950s."
The source said the party would not accept a policy which would leave "a large number of children behind at a relatively young age".
Some in the party are said to feel today's newspaper report, the first they knew about the plan, was an attempt to bounce them into accepting the changes.
Foreign Office Minister, Jeremy Browne - a Liberal Democrat - told the BBC's Daily Politics: "What will be the guiding principle over rank and file Lib Dems is to have a system where everybody is able to realise their potential, that you don't have glass ceilings put in at different layers."
But it is not just Liberal Democrats MPs, the junior partners in the coalition government with the Conservatives, who are unhappy with the proposals.
Conservative MP Graham Stuart, chair of the Education Select Committee, told BBC Radio 4's The World at One he was "sceptical" about changing the system of secondary school qualifications in England.
He said the plan had "come out of the blue" and asked: "How will it help close the gap between rich and poor? How will it increase social mobility?"
Shadow schools minister Kevin Brennan: ''Michael Gove is in danger of completely ripping up a system that actually works''
For Labour, shadow schools minister Kevin Brennan said Mr Gove's plan would take the exam system "back to the 1950s".
"GCSEs may well need improving, but a two-tier exam system which divides children into winners and losers at 14 is not the answer," he said.
Mr Gove was called to Parliament to answer questions from MPs about the leaked plans.
He said the current exams system needed to be improved: "Children are working harder than ever but we are hearing that the system is not working for them. We want to tackle the culture of competitive dumbing down."
He said rigour needed to be restored to the system if England was to keep pace with educational improvements in some other countries.
Russell Hobby, the general secretary of the National Association of Head Teachers, welcomed the move towards having a single exam board per subject, which he said was sensible and would "remove a lot of concerns about the system".
"But a move to a two-tier (exam) system does not sound a good step forward," he added, saying such a change would mean choices about children's futures being taken at too young an age.
As control of education in the UK is devolved, Mr Gove's plans are for England only. It would be up to Wales and Northern Ireland to decide whether to follow suit. In Scotland, pupils take Standard Grades, Highers and Advanced Highers rather than GCSEs and A-levels.
The Education Minister for Wales, Leighton Andrews, has said Wales will not return to O-level-style exams.
At 22:50:30 in ScotlandThe Commonwealth Games is 11 days of non-stop action.
At 22:39:20 in HeadlinesThe United Nations has sent its first aid convoy into Syria without the consent of the government in Damascus.
At 22:35:10 in HeadlinesThe US says it has evidence that Russia has fired artillery across the border targeting Ukrainian military positions.
At 22:32:56 in SportManchester City have released a video that appears to show Porto defender Eliaquim Mangala signing for the club.
At 22:27:17 in SportJersey's badminton team cruised to a 5-0 win over Mauritius in their opening match of the 2014 Commonwealth Games.
At 22:25:18 in Northern IrelandPolice in County Down have warned skinny dippers that they could be placed on the sex offenders register.
At 22:04:58 in SportSir Bradley Wiggins says he will not ride the Tour de France again after telling the BBC that road racing is "cut-throat" with "no kind of loyalty".
At 22:04:26 in WorldThe life of a liberal journalist in Pakistan is not an easy one. Write about someone fighting a blasphemy case, or someone whose faith is considered heresy, and you may very soon find yourself in deep trouble.
At 21:56:45 in SportOn another sun-buttered day in Glasgow, it was the only grey cloud in the sky: the announcement that double Olympic champion Mo Farah was pulling out of the Commonwealth Games .
At 21:53:33 in SportSwimmer Jazz Carlin says she is not too disheartened despite finishing sixth in the women's 200m freestyle final at the Commonwealth Games.
Harvard CitationBBC News, 2012. Nick Clegg blasts Michael Gove over scrap GCSE plan [Online] (Updated 21st Jun 2012)
Available at: http://www.ukwirednews.com/news/1436153/Nick-Clegg-blasts-Michael-Gove-over-scrap-GCSE-plan [Accessed 24th Jul 2014]
News In Other Categories
The immersive film-experience company, Secret Cinema, has cancelled the opening night of a special screening of 1980s film Back To The Future.
Police in County Down have warned skinny dippers that they could be placed on the sex offenders register.
Amazon has reported a loss of $126m (£74m) in the second quarter and warned that sales could slow in the current quarter.
Taxpayers could be hit with a bill for up to £700m after the government reportedly lost a legal battle with Fujitsu over a failed NHS IT system.
The Commonwealth Games is 11 days of non-stop action.
A decision not to publish a document on the conclusions of a consultation on the planned M4 relief road has been criticised.