To sue or not to sue? Parthenon Marbles activists debate
Published: 21st Jun 2012 02:42:33
Activists from around the world seeking the return of the Parthenon sculptures to Athens have met in London to discuss their strategy as Greece faces troubled times.
"The Olympics are a four-yearly reminder to the world of all we owe to Greece," said former MP Eddie O'Hara - who chairs the British Committee for the Reunification of the Parthenon Marbles.
The meeting, he added, "ought to remind people in London and throughout the world that there's one debt to Greece that will never be repaid until those sculptures in the British Museum are returned."
But he said there was a "hiatus" in the campaign because economic woes meant not much action could be expected from the Greek authorities.
All agreed they should continue to work to inform public opinion, especially in Britain, to encourage the UK government and British Museum to return the sculptures. But there were differing views on what more was needed.
"There is no excuse," said Emanuel Comino, head of the Australian committee for the Restitution of the Marbles, for the British and Greek governments not getting together to discuss demands for the sculptures held in London to be reunited with those still in Athens.
However, Whitehall insists the dispute is a matter for the British Museum, which it says is independent.
And the museum says its Parthenon sculptures, displayed in the same building as relics of so many other civilisations, are "an important representation of ancient Athenian civilisation in the context of world history."
Those at the meeting were divided on whether the Greeks should step up pressure on Britain by pursuing their claim in court.
"I want to see the Marbles of the Parthenon reunited, not because of some legal argument but because culturally and ethically it's the right thing to do," said Mr O'Hara.
But Michael Reppas, who chairs the American Committee for the Reunification of the Marbles, said litigation should not be ruled out. "I absolutely don't believe it's a foregone conclusion that the issue will be unsuccessful for the Greeks."
The prospect of a court battle raises the pace and "stirs people and makes people act," he said.
Most thought a claim would have to be pursued in England - but other venues were possible, Mr Reppas told BBC News, such as Athens or the United States.
Some thought Greece could not be expected to enter such a battle - but Mr Reppas thought it could be "a great morale booster for the Greek people right now".
Former MP Andrew Dismore said a challenge now to the British Museum's right to have acquired the marbles in 1816 faced insurmountable obstacles.
A court battle would be an "expensive and time-consuming sideshow", and losing it would do major damage to the campaign to send the Marbles back, Mr Dismore told the meeting.
He believed an act of parliament could overcome the legal restrictions which the British Museum cites as preventing it from disposing of the sculptures. All that was lacking was political will.
Greek-South African human rights advocate - and lawyer to Nelson Mandela - George Bizos said "we should try to increase the number of our friends" in parliament, the universities and schools, and the media, until the British said "Let's come to terms".
"But the threat of litigation cannot be set aside altogether," he said.
If there were a court case the Greeks might lose, he said, but the evidence would prove the House of Commons was "taken for a ride" when it decided in the 19th century that British envoy Lord Elgin was the legitimate owner of the Marbles which he had removed from the Acropolis and shipped to the UK.
This point was reinforced by archaeologist Dr Elena Korka who told of correspondence between Lord Elgin and his successor.
The letters indicate that "There was no legality whatsoever in Elgin's acquisition of the Marbles and he knew it well," she said.
At 21:02:53 in HeadlinesAn assistant of American painter Jasper Johns has pleaded guilty to selling artworks worth $6.5m (£3.9m) he stole from the artist's studio
At 20:44:59 in EnglandEngineers say the underlying condition of Southampton's Central Bridge is much worse than originally thought, prolonging repair work.
At 20:39:18 in EnglandAn inspection has revealed a Dorset prison still has problems with drugs, legal highs and the treatment of people with mental health difficulties.
At 20:37:12 in WorldThe US is considering making aid drops to Shia Turkmen in northern Iraq who are under siege from Islamic State (IS) militants, US defence sources say.
At 20:27:09 in EnglandA man has been arrested in Birmingham after he was found hiding behind the air spoiler of a lorry that had travelled from Calais, police said.
At 20:17:33 in EnglandHundreds of drivers had their licences revoked in the West Midlands because their eyesight was too poor, according to figures from the DVLA.
At 20:09:02 in HeadlinesBy artificially activating circuits in the brain, scientists have turned negative memories into positive ones.
At 19:56:46 in HeadlinesThe mother of Steven Sotloff, a US journalist being held by Islamic State (IS) militants, has made an emotional video appeal for his release.
At 19:48:34 in EnglandWater voles have returned to every county in England following a reintroduction programme in Cornwall, the Environment Agency has said.
At 19:26:37 in EnglandTwo men have been arrested in connection with suspected child prostitution, following an investigation into an escort agency.
Harvard CitationBBC News, 2012. To sue or not to sue? Parthenon Marbles activists debate [Online] (Updated 21st Jun 2012)
Available at: http://www.ukwirednews.com/news/1435967/To-sue-or-not-to-sue-Parthenon-Marbles-activists-debate [Accessed 27th Aug 2014]
News In Other Categories
The UK is to give an extra £10m in humanitarian aid to Iraqis displaced by the conflict in the country.
The number of people looking for work in France rose 0.8% in July to a new record.
A Virgin Atlantic passenger aircraft was forced to make an emergency landing at Edinburgh Airport after suffering a loss of cabin pressure shortly after take-off.
Sting has announced two concerts to help celebrate the 10th anniversary of the Sage Gateshead arts venue.
Tributes have been paid to a Carmarthenshire man who died while working on an island in Thailand.
An assistant of American painter Jasper Johns has pleaded guilty to selling artworks worth $6.5m (£3.9m) he stole from the artist's studio