Jailed man to get damages for Coventry Crown Court error
Published: 31st May 2012 11:30:43
Failures in the courts service led to a man awaiting trial on robbery charges being detained for too long, senior judges have ruled.
The High Court heard a lack of resources at Coventry Crown Court led to delays in the trial of Clark McAuley, who was charged last July.
He was held on remand for seven months, more than a month over the custody limit. Judges ruled it "unlawful".
HM Courts and Tribunals Service said it had reviewed its guidance to courts.
McAuley, who went on to admit conspiracy to rob and has been jailed for four-and-a-half years, is due to receive damages at a separate hearing.
Last July, McAuley was charged with conspiracy to commit robbery, dangerous driving and handling stolen goods.
He was due to stand trial in December but it was rescheduled for February due a lack of availability of court rooms and judges.
The court then extended his custody time limit, which sets out the maximum period allowed before a trial is brought.
McAuley's lawyers applied for a judicial review and the decision to extend the deadline was quashed at the High Court, it has emerged.
In their ruling, President of the Queen's Bench Sir John Thomas and Mr Justice Silber ruled: "There had been a systemic failure in Her Majesty's Courts and Tribunals Service (HMCTS) by failing to provide sufficient funds to enable defendants in custody to be tried within the maximum period allowed by law."
They said their ruling, published in March, depended in part on the established principle that "justice delayed is justice denied".
The judges said "unlawful instructions" had been given at Coventry Crown Court "as a result of failures of management".
Routine cases should be heard within custody time limits except in "highly exceptional circumstances", they said.
Custody time limits vary, depending on the offence or combination of offences a defendant is charged with.
HMCTS, which is part of the Ministry of Justice, accepted that the custody time limit should not have been extended in the case of McAuley.
A spokesman said the service worked with the judiciary to ensure court cases were listed efficiently.
He said: "In light of this judgment we have, in partnership with the judiciary, formally reviewed and revised our listing guidance to ensure that cases are reviewed, prioritised, and listed having fully considered any implications in respect of custody time limits."
At 08:44:54 in SportFormer world number one Luke Donald enhanced his bid for a first title since 2012 as a 66 put him two ahead after three rounds of the RBC Heritage.
At 08:40:49 in EnglandThe Royal Navy patrol vessel, HMS Dasher, will visit her twinned town in Cornwall later for a short stay.
At 08:10:40 in EnglandTwo illegal raves have been stopped from going ahead in Devon after police were alerted by members of the public.
At 06:58:11 in HeadlinesFour French journalists have arrived back in France after their release from 10 months of captivity in Syria, Agence France Presse reports.
At 05:51:11 in HeadlinesThe Easter break offers no break from the political spotlight for those hoping to win over voters in the general election in 13 months' time - at least judging from Easter Sunday's newspapers.
At 05:27:39 in EnglandThe Duke and Duchess of Cambridge have marked Easter Sunday by attending a church service in Sydney.
At 04:49:43 in HeadlinesFamilies of passengers on a sunken South Korean ferry have protested angrily over the rescue operation.
At 04:24:57 in HeadlinesA businessman appointed by the prime minister to head a quango managing public funds has resigned after reports that he had been declared bankrupt.
At 02:44:02 in HeadlinesOrthodox Easter messages from patriarchs in Kiev and Moscow have highlighted the deep division in Ukraine, where a tense stand-off is continuing in the east.
At 02:25:05 in HeadlinesIslamic extremism is the "most deadly" threat to charities in England and Wales, the Charity Commission has said.
Harvard CitationBBC News, 2012. Jailed man to get damages for Coventry Crown Court error [Online] (Updated 31st May 2012)
Available at: http://www.ukwirednews.com/news/1431995/Jailed-man-to-get-damages-for-Coventry-Crown-Court-error [Accessed 20th Apr 2014]
News In Other Categories
BBC Two is celebrating its 50th anniversary on Sunday, 20 April, having been home to many landmark programmes over the decades.
With an international museum, a new train station, a marina and an enormous park all in the pipeline, there is no end to the ambition in the masterplan city planners have drawn up for the Dundee waterfront. They are even looking at building an urban beach which doubles as an ice rink.
The demand for bigger buttocks in Venezuela means some women will even have banned injections to achieve them, putting their health at risk.
Former world number one Luke Donald enhanced his bid for a first title since 2012 as a 66 put him two ahead after three rounds of the RBC Heritage.
Millions of people dream of starting their own company, but only some are brave enough to take the leap.
Four French journalists have arrived back in France after their release from 10 months of captivity in Syria, Agence France Presse reports.