Postmistress murderer Robin Garbutt loses appeal
Published: 24th May 2012 15:40:59
A shopkeeper who bludgeoned his postmistress wife to death has lost a challenge against his murder conviction at the Court of Appeal.
Robin Garbutt, 46, was jailed for life in April 2011 and ordered to serve a minimum of 20 years in prison.
The jury at his trial heard he beat his 40-year-old wife Diana to death in their home above the village store in Melsonby, North Yorkshire.
Three Court of Appeal judges in London said his conviction was safe.
A jury at Teesside Crown Court heard he battered his wife to death in their bedroom before opening their post office and shop.
During his trial, Garbutt claimed an intruder with a gun told him "don't do anything stupid, we've got your wife" before robbing him as he worked, and that moments later he discovered his wife's body in bed in their living quarters.
The fresh material relied on in the appeal related to Post Office records going back to 2004.
Announcing the court's decision to reject the challenge, Lord Justice Hughes said Garbutt's case was founded on the emergence of evidence which was not before the jury because its existence was unknown.
He said: "It affects, and is said to undermine, one part of the evidence heard by the jury at the trial.
"It is quite clear that the evidence was not available at the trial.
"It takes the form of accounting records from the headquarters of the Post Office and its accuracy is not in dispute. The issue is as to its significance."
Lord Justice Hughes concluded: "We are quite satisfied that this conviction is not unsafe and that the late disclosure of the additional Post Office records does not render it so.
"The appeal must accordingly be dismissed."
At 01:59:02 in EnglandGlastonbury Festival has been granted a new ten-year licence.
At 01:40:57 in HeadlinesWhat's it like to live in the poorest part of the poorest country in the European Union?
At 01:39:03 in HeadlinesConservative Sir Peter Tapsell has asked more questions of David Cameron at his weekly Prime Minister's Questions sessions than any other backbench MP, BBC research has shown.
At 01:34:13 in WorldNigerian President Goodluck Jonathan wants the world to believe he and his government are serious about ending corruption. But two recent events have sent out the opposite message.
At 01:33:14 in EnglandPupils at St Andrew's Primary School, which is due to close in August 2015, have been allocated places at other Guernsey schools.
At 01:27:37 in WorldTwo years after the murder of an outspoken female councillor ushered in new legislation outlawing political violence against women in Bolivia, campaigners say a culture of harassment remains, as Paula Dear reports from La Paz.
At 01:23:35 in WorldRussia's move into part of Ukraine has caused genuine unease in neighbouring countries like Poland and the three Baltic states and a sense that they also are under threat.
At 01:18:33 in EnglandDorset Police's proposals to reduce station opening hours and close front desks have been put on hold until 2015.
At 00:57:36 in WorldFrom the sharp and potentially painful points on a kidney stone, to a head louse egg firmly glued to a hair follicle - the annual Wellcome Image Awards celebrate the best in science imaging talent and techniques. Take a close-up look at some of the winning images.
At 00:52:03 in WorldIt's a busy Monday night at Whispers strip bar in the oil boomtown of Williston, North Dakota.
Harvard CitationBBC News, 2012. Postmistress murderer Robin Garbutt loses appeal [Online] (Updated 24th May 2012)
Available at: http://www.ukwirednews.com/news/1430675/Postmistress-murderer-Robin-Garbutt-loses-appeal [Accessed 12th Mar 2014]
News In Other Categories
Twenty-five years ago Sir Tim Berners-Lee was working at a physics laboratory at CERN, in Switzerland, when he came up with a proposal for the World Wide Web.
Women who suffer swelling following breast cancer treatment should be encouraged to exercise, say experts.
The family of a pensioner who died has demanded an inquiry into all hospitals under the control of a south Wales health board.
Rapper Professor Green has been charged with drinking and driving.
Glastonbury Festival has been granted a new ten-year licence.
Two students who died after a driver's car mounted a pavement and hit them would still be alive if he had told the truth, an inquiry has heard.