Education Secretary Michael Gove loses High Court battle
Published: 17th May 2012 19:44:29
Education Secretary Michael Gove has lost a High Court battle with Essex County Council over government cuts to nursery funding.
The council claimed Mr Gove breached equality laws when he slashed part of its budget by £10m in 2010 - hitting the county's disabled children.
The High Court ruled Mr Gove's decision was unlawful and must be reviewed.
Mr Justice Mitting found Mr Gove had not met his legal obligations under equality laws.
Andrew Sharland, for Essex County Council, told the court the council was told its budget for nursery and primary school building projects would be about £27m for 2008 to 2011.
It said it had allocated more than £26m of that money, by June 2010, to building projects aimed at improving pre-school education, particularly for the disabled.
But when Mr Gove announced his cuts in July that year, the council was told to review its spending and identify any "uncommitted" funds, the court heard.
A dispute then arose between Westminster and Essex over how much money had been allocated - with government accountants estimating more than £12m was still in the pot, but the council insisting they had less then £2m left.
Essex County Council argued that by not consulting it before cutting funding by £10.7m, Mr Gove breached his "equality duties".
Mr Sharland told the court: "The grant was expressly aimed at meeting the needs of disabled children. Further, the level of funding was calculated taking into account the level of deprivation in a particular area."
He added: "It is clear that equality issues were neither 'central' to the decision making process nor exercised in substance with rigor and an open mind."
Government lawyers insisted the decision making process was correctly handled.
Mr Justice Mitting ruled: "Local authorities obviously would have greater knowledge of the impact the cuts would have on families in their areas and it would be reasonable for the Secretary of State to assume that any such detailed assessment would be carried out by the local authority."
He added: "Accordingly, I do not accept that the Secretary of State, either personally or through his officials, fully discharged the duty upon them."
The Department for Education has yet to comment.
At 17:02:44 in EnglandTwelve new victims have made allegations of child sexual abuse in Rotherham since a report found at least 1,400 children were abused, police say.
At 17:02:03 in ScotlandPolice have appealed for help in tracing a woman and three children from the Pollok area of Glasgow who have been missing for the past week.
At 16:59:50 in HeadlinesFour UN peacekeepers have been killed and 15 injured by a landmine in northern Mali.
At 16:52:29 in HealthA global military intervention is needed to curb the largest ever Ebola outbreak, according to the medical charity Medecins Sans Frontieres.
At 16:50:46 in Northern IrelandA 20-year plan has been proposed to improve education in the area with the worst attainment record in Belfast.
At 16:50:13 in EnglandA man has been found guilty of bombarding a Labour MP with abusive messages on Twitter after she supported a feminist campaign.
At 16:46:49 in EnglandA major road improvement scheme has been delayed by more than a month because damage is worse than previously thought.
At 16:45:30 in SportIndia sent England to a humiliating nine-wicket defeat to win the fourth one-day international at Edgbaston and the five-match series 3-0.
At 16:44:45 in ScotlandEdinburgh City Council is examining ways to make a church bell quieter after learning it exceeds World Health Organisation night-time noise limits.
At 16:34:32 in Northern IrelandA court has ordered Irish police to apprehend a 16-year-old boy who had absconded from hospital.
Harvard CitationBBC News, 2012. Education Secretary Michael Gove loses High Court battle [Online] (Updated 17th May 2012)
Available at: http://www.ukwirednews.com/news/1429306/Education-Secretary-Michael-Gove-loses-High-Court-battle [Accessed 2nd Sep 2014]
News In Other Categories
Twelve new victims have made allegations of child sexual abuse in Rotherham since a report found at least 1,400 children were abused, police say.
Police have appealed for help in tracing a woman and three children from the Pollok area of Glasgow who have been missing for the past week.
A 20-year plan has been proposed to improve education in the area with the worst attainment record in Belfast.
A man has been found guilty of bombarding a Labour MP with abusive messages on Twitter after she supported a feminist campaign.
US oilfield services firm Halliburton says it has reached a $1.1bn (£660m) settlement to meet the majority of claims against it for its role in the 2010 Gulf of Mexico oil spill.
A diver who died following an incident at a disused Gwynedd quarry has been named.