Complaints over use of 'Asian' label in grooming cases
Published: 16th May 2012 21:07:02
Groups representing Sikh and Hindu communities have complained about the term "Asian" being used to describe the men involved in grooming trials.
Earlier this month, nine men were jailed for being part of a sex ring in Rochdale which groomed girls for sex.
The groups said the men involved were "almost always of Pakistani origin" and the term "Asian" was inaccurate.
The Ramadan Foundation has said grooming is "a significant problem for the British Pakistani community".
The joint statement was released by the Network of Sikh Organisations UK, The Hindu Forum of Britain, and The Sikh Media Monitoring Group UK.
It says the reluctance of the media and the government to discuss the "disproportionate representation of Muslims in such cases" and the fact victims are "almost always non-Muslim girls" is adding to the cause of far-right groups such as the BNP.
It said blanket use of the word "Asian" was "unfair to other communities of Asian origin".
"We believe that in this case the government itself is sanctioning the use of term Asian as a way of clouding responsibility," the groups say.
The groups say sex gangs have targeted Hindu and Sikh girls but the cases are rarely reported as they seldom reach the courts.
The statement says: "We believe that political correctness stifles debate and will not facilitate a frank and mature discussion or solutions to get to the root of why the above pattern is emerging in these crimes and how to help find a solution to the problem.
"We will not be able to do that if we mask the identity of those involved based on misguided views of 'protecting a vulnerable community' of the perpetrators and not looking at the vulnerable community of victims."
Last Week Mohammed Shafiq, chief executive of The Ramadhan Foundation, said: "There is an over-representation [of Asian men] amongst recent convictions in the crime of on-street grooming [and] there should be no silence in addressing the issue of race as this is central to the actions of these criminals," he said.
He said community elders were "burying their heads" over the issue and police and local councils should not "be frightened" to address the problem, as there was "a strong lesson that you cannot ignore race or be over-sensitive".
On Monday, the chair of the Equalities and Human Rights Commission, Trevor Phillips, said the race of the men involved could not be ignored and it was "fatuous" to deny racial and cultural factors.
But assistant chief constable Steve Heywood, of Greater Manchester Police, said the case was not about race, but about "adults preying on vulnerable young children".
Liverpool Crown Court heard the nine men plied their victims, one as young as 13, with drink and drugs so they could "pass them around" and use them for sex.
The case sparked protests by far-right groups but police insisted the grooming was not "racially motivated".
At 23:03:47 in SportManchester United "made mistakes" last season under David Moyes, according to club legend Sir Bobby Charlton.
At 22:53:22 in ScotlandThe Commonwealth Games is 11 days of non-stop action.
At 22:50:06 in SportEngland are guaranteed Commonwealth Games gold in table tennis' mixed doubles following Friday's semi-finals.
At 22:44:27 in ScotlandUsain Bolt has made his much anticipated Commonwealth Games debut - and again denied making disparaging remarks about Glasgow 2014.
At 22:42:38 in Northern IrelandHundreds of people have attended a public meeting to discuss fracking in County Fermanagh.
At 22:30:05 in TechnologyIf you live out your life on the internet, getting knocked offline can ruin your day.
At 22:29:16 in BusinessNegotiations between Argentina and its creditors should be resumed urgently, US judge Thomas Griesa has said.
At 22:18:11 in BusinessWith house prices growing faster than incomes in many parts of the UK, is your house making more money than you do? Find out by using the calculator below.
At 22:17:35 in HeadlinesPresident Barack Obama has defended CIA Director John Brennan and acknowledged the US tortured prisoners after 9/11.
At 22:07:12 in SportDerry City moved up to fifth place in the Premier Division by hammering Bohemians 4-0 on Friday night.
Harvard CitationBBC News, 2012. Complaints over use of 'Asian' label in grooming cases [Online] (Updated 16th May 2012)
Available at: http://www.ukwirednews.com/news/1429194/Complaints-over-use-of-Asian-label-in-grooming-cases [Accessed 1st Aug 2014]
News In Other Categories
Manchester United "made mistakes" last season under David Moyes, according to club legend Sir Bobby Charlton.
The Commonwealth Games is 11 days of non-stop action.
Life expectancy in South Africa has increased dramatically over the last decade, mainly thanks to life-saving Aids drugs, a government report says.
One hundred years ago this summer Britain and her Empire stood on the brink of war. Frantic last-minute diplomacy had come to nothing - and armies were mobilising across Europe.
Negotiations between Argentina and its creditors should be resumed urgently, US judge Thomas Griesa has said.
A 16-year-old boy who beat and raped his ex-girlfriend in a park in Luton, leaving her with the mental age of an eight year old, has been given a discretionary life sentence.