Dog bone row driver unfairly dismissed by racehorse owner
Published: 11th May 2012 10:09:15
A driver sacked by a racehorse owner for feeding a piece of leftover lamb to an ailing Labrador has won a claim for unfair dismissal.
Property tycoon Raymond Mould did not act reasonably in dismissing Ivor James, 60, when his dog needed surgery, an employment tribunal judge ruled.
Mr James was fired with immediate effect two days after feeding a piece of gristle to the dog at Mr Mould's country estate in Gloucestershire.
Compensation will be decided later.
Mr James was sacked from his post at Wormington Manor, near Broadway, shortly after Merlin the dog was rushed to a veterinary hospital on 5 November last year.
Mr Mould, whose wealth was estimated at £60m in 2010, told the tribunal Mr James was "grossly irresponsible" in feeding a lamb bone to the dog, who he claimed could have been killed.
But Mr James, who also worked as a handyman for Mr Mould, told the hearing Merlin, who had recently undergone surgery after eating conkers, was only given the "fatty end" of a rack of lamb.
The claimant wasn't even given the courtesy of a face-to-face discussion”
"The dog was sat there begging so I gave him a piece of lamb meat. It was just what was left when I finished my dinner," he told the tribunal.
"I didn't consider it was a bone - as far as I was concerned it was a piece of fatty meat."
Judge Christopher Camp said he had no reason to doubt the account of the incident given by the claimant.
The tribunal heard Mr James was sacked during a 12-minute phonecall.
Mr Camp said Mr Mould admitted he decided to dismiss Mr James before he picked up the phone, adding: "I don't accept that it is enough to give the claimant merely an opportunity to change the decision-maker's mind."
Mr Mould, who also has homes in London and France, failed to speak to a housekeeper who witnessed the alleged misconduct or to conduct an adequate investigation about the incident, the judge noted.
"No reasonable employer in Mr Mould's shoes would have done this," the judge said.
"The claimant wasn't even given the courtesy of a face-to-face discussion."
Although Mr Mould acted in the mistaken but genuinely-held belief that the claimant had caused Merlin to undergo emergency surgery, Judge Camp said he was satisfied the dismissal was substantively unfair.
At 15:02:39 in SportNorth Ferriby manager Billy Heath has appealed to Gainsborough Trinity to act "professionally" in their Conference North decider against AFC Telford.
At 15:02:36 in HeadlinesRival Palestinian factions Fatah and Hamas have announced a reconciliation deal after a meeting in the Gaza Strip.
At 14:58:30 in EnglandA body supporting NHS groups in the eastern region has warned it could cease to operate in its "current form".
At 14:53:58 in EnglandSteven Gerrard's cousin, who died in the Hillsborough disaster, would have been "very proud" of the England captain, his mother told an inquest.
At 14:52:57 in EnglandA list of the schools Ofsted has been sent in to inspect over an alleged plot by Muslim hard-liners to seize control of governing bodies has been published.
At 14:52:04 in ScotlandControversial plans to end the need for evidence in Scottish criminal trials to come from two sources have been delayed by the government.
At 14:48:29 in ScotlandThe oil and gas industry is worth about £35bn to the UK economy, according to a new study.
At 14:46:07 in WalesA benefits cheat who claimed to have a fear of open spaces has been jailed for a year at Merthyr Crown court after being caught working as a tour guide in South America.
At 14:44:41 in EnglandJurors in the indecent assault trial of publicist Max Clifford have been told they can return a majority verdict.
At 14:42:23 in HeadlinesFor centuries, gardeners have put shards of pottery - "crocks" - at the bottom of plant pots to increase drainage. But a new study has debunked the tradition, writes Tom de Castella.
Harvard CitationBBC News, 2012. Dog bone row driver unfairly dismissed by racehorse owner [Online] (Updated 11th May 2012)
Available at: http://www.ukwirednews.com/news/1427895/Dog-bone-row-driver-unfairly-dismissed-by-racehorse-owner [Accessed 23rd Apr 2014]
News In Other Categories
A benefits cheat who claimed to have a fear of open spaces has been jailed for a year at Merthyr Crown court after being caught working as a tour guide in South America.
Jurors in the indecent assault trial of publicist Max Clifford have been told they can return a majority verdict.
Controversial plans to end the need for evidence in Scottish criminal trials to come from two sources have been delayed by the government.
Three people have appeared in court charged in connection with an incident at a loyalist protest camp in north Belfast.
The Football Association was hit by a £34m drop in broadcasting rights income last season compared with 2011-12.
A body supporting NHS groups in the eastern region has warned it could cease to operate in its "current form".