Leading vet criticises ritual slaughter of animals
Published: 5th May 2012 03:01:30
A leading vet has criticised the "unacceptable" rise in the number of animals killed in ritual slaughter.
Ritual slaughter is lawful in the UK and the EU to satisfy the dietary requirements of Jews and Muslims.
Prof Bill Reilly, former president of the British Veterinary Association, said estimates suggested more animals were slaughtered than was necessary.
The Food Standards Agency (FSA) said its own figures showed most animals were stunned before being killed.
The FSA conducted a survey into animal welfare in slaughterhouses in September.
A spokesman said: "The results indicate that the number of animals not stunned prior to slaughter is relatively low, accounting for 3% of cattle, 10% of sheep and goats, and 4% of poultry.
"They also show that the majority of animals destined for the halal trade in both the red and white meat sectors are stunned before slaughter."
The FSA said full details of the survey would be published ahead of a discussion at a board meeting on 22 May.
But Prof Reilly, writing in the Veterinary Record, said: "In my view, the current situation is not acceptable and, if we cannot eliminate non-stunning, we need to keep it to the minimum.
"This means restricting the use of halal and kosher meat to those communities that require it for their religious beliefs and, where possible, convincing them of the acceptability of the stunned alternatives."
He suggested some abattoirs might be refusing to stun animals simply to cut costs.
UK legislation allows halal (Muslim) or schecita (Jewish) "non-stun" slaughter as long as it does not cause "unnecessary suffering".
But Prof Reilly said he witnessed schecita slaughter in the 1970s and he wrote: "The distress, fear and pain were there for all to see in the abattoir."
Prof Reilly said his own estimates suggested around two million animals, mostly poultry, were killed in the UK each year without stunning for the orthodox Jewish community.
Halal meat now accounted for 25% of the entire UK meat market, Prof Reilly added. Anecdotal evidence suggested that almost half of lambs destined for slaughter were killed without prior stunning.
Joyce D'Silva, from the charity Compassion in World Farming (CWF), said: "Judaism and Islam believe that animals are creatures of God; science tells us that they are sentient beings, who can suffer.
"If you hold either view, or both, then your principle concern must be to ensure the least possible suffering for the animal concerned.
"Therefore animals should be handled with care and stunned effectively before their throats are cut in order to minimise their distress and pain.
"Consumers should be able to tell how the animals they eat are reared, transported and slaughtered," he added.
At 14:00:21 in WorldAfghan presidential candidate Abdullah Abdullah remains the frontrunner with 80% of votes counted, officials say.
At 13:54:55 in BusinessPublic sector union Unison is to ballot local government workers and school staff in England for strikes after members rejected a 1% pay offer.
At 13:54:06 in ScotlandA man who throttled a 12-year-old girl until she collapsed unconscious has been ordered to carry out unpaid community work.
At 13:52:47 in SportNorthampton Saints have made four changes for their Amlin Challenge Cup semi-final against Harlequins.
At 13:45:28 in EnglandThree men have been arrested on suspicion of murder after the death of a man at a flat in Peterborough.
At 13:44:57 in HealthSeven-year-olds are happier when they are allowed some sweets, snacks and television time, rather than none at all, suggests a study of children's well-being.
At 13:44:36 in EnglandThe M25 in Hertfordshire is blocked in both directions after an articulated lorry caught fire on the anti-clockwise carriageway, police said.
At 13:44:16 in ScotlandPolice have announced a crackdown on fans attempting to carry fireworks into this weekend's Edinburgh derby.
At 13:43:39 in EnglandA "rigorous investigation" is under way at the Royal Cornwall Hospitals Trust (RCHT) after three so-called "never events" in under a month.
At 13:43:23 in EnglandA waste firm has been fined £13,500 for causing bad odours around its processing site.
Harvard CitationBBC News, 2012. Leading vet criticises ritual slaughter of animals [Online] (Updated 5th May 2012)
Available at: http://www.ukwirednews.com/news/1426688/Leading-vet-criticises-ritual-slaughter-of-animals [Accessed 24th Apr 2014]
News In Other Categories
Afghan presidential candidate Abdullah Abdullah remains the frontrunner with 80% of votes counted, officials say.
A dozen previously unknown works created by Andy Warhol have been recovered from 30-year-old Amiga disks.
Plans to hold a three-day music festival in Ceredigion have been scrapped after organisers withdrew their application.
Coronation Street actress Barbara Knox has pleaded not guilty to drinking and driving.
Shots have been fired at a house in west Belfast in an incident being treated as a hate crime by police.
Supporters of Scottish independence have questioned why the BBC has not resigned from the CBI over the business group's referendum stance.