The flawed concept that saw voters reject city mayors
Published: 4th May 2012 18:18:00
Voters have spoken. With the exception of Bristol, England's biggest cities did not want directly elected mayors.
Perhaps the scale of the no vote wasn't that surprising in the end.
This was a top-down campaign. It was the government that was keen on the idea of mayors. Voters in the cities needed to be persuaded - and the case clearly wasn't made to them.
Without any grass roots enthusiasm, the debate was often confined to the political elite, leaving voters unmoved. Support from business was thin on the ground.
And at a time when people take a dim view of politicians, asking them to vote for an extra one in the shape of mayor clearly didn't appeal.
I think the government also hoped city voters would look at London with envy and want their own mayoral contest.
But anecdotally many of the voters I spoke to in Newcastle were turned off by the personality politics of Boris v Ken.
They didn't fancy seeing their own versions of spats in lifts.
There was also an incoherence in the government's proposals that chimes with the other problems that have dogged the coalition in the last few weeks.
The government says it's keen on handing power to the people and, in truth, giving people a vote on whether to have a mayor fits in with that.
But at the same time the government is imposing directly-elected police commissioners on communities without any referendum.
If mayors are as good for communities as the government claims, why not just introduce them without a vote?
Then there is the problem of powers.
The government offered the referendums without specifying what might be on offer.
And while Nick Clegg told the cities that they could have extra powers whether they had a mayor or not, the PM seemed to suggest those that voted for mayors would get special treatment.
But in reality other government policies were actually removing powers.
The introduction of police commissioners meant the new city mayors would have less power over law and order than existing council leaders.
The growth of free schools and academies would also see them have more limited power over education.
Then there was the government's argument that city mayors would have influence beyond local authority boundaries.
There was never any guarantee that could happen, just a vague desire.
If you really wanted that sort of politician, why not create mayors covering wider metropolitan areas - for Tyneside, Greater Manchester or West Yorkshire?
They might have been able to go toe-to-toe with their equivalent in London.
All this incoherence weakened the arguments of the yes campaign.
At a time when people take a dim view of politicians, asking them to vote for an extra one in the shape of mayor clearly didn't appeal”
If the government is serious about handing powers to communities, it will now have to look for other solutions.
The government saw elected mayors as the key to the unresolved problem of English devolution.
In 2004, Labour saw elected regional assemblies as the solution.
Both have now been firmly rejected by the electorate.
But the problem of how to take power out of Whitehall remains.
The reality now is that the government will have to work with what's already there - the existing councils.
And there is a model for that. The councils in Greater Manchester have secured a city deal worth millions of pounds by signing a deal to co-operate together.
Others like Newcastle have been made to wait for similar extra powers and resources because the government wanted to see which way the mayoral referendums went.
It'll be up to the government now to prove it is still serious about handing powers to England's big cities.
But it will also be up to the cities to show leadership by co-operating with their neighbours to secure these city deals, and proving they'll use the resources and powers wisely.
There's little question our big cities are crucial to getting the economy growing again.
On that point the government was right, but now it must find other ways of unlocking that potential.
And as for David Cameron's proposed cabinet of city mayors, he may have to search for a smaller room than he originally booked.
At 17:58:58 in HeadlinesOne of Venezuela's main opposition leaders, Leopoldo Lopez, has told a judge in Caracas that his trial on charges of inciting violence will be a test for the country's democracy.
At 17:53:55 in SportSir Bradley Wiggins was denied a first Commonwealth Games gold as Australia beat England in the final of the 4,000m team pursuit in Glasgow.
At 17:53:22 in SportJersey's Dan Halksworth finished in 17th place in the Commonwealth Games triathlon, despite impressing on the bike section in Glasgow.
At 17:51:59 in EnglandA list of possible gypsy and traveller sites in Teesside has been rejected by councillors.
At 17:48:27 in SportSecond qualifying round, second leg
At 17:44:39 in HeadlinesSouth Africa's Human Rights Commission (SAHRC) has found a public school guilty of hate speech towards black and mixed-race pupils.
At 17:44:05 in ScotlandA drugs mule from Ayr has been jailed for three years after he admitted attempting to smuggle heroin worth almost £13,000 into Shetland.
At 17:40:20 in EnglandThe father and brother of one of the Newcastle United fans who died when Malaysia Airlines flight MH17 crashed have returned from the Netherlands.
At 17:39:09 in EntertainmentThe immersive film-experience company, Secret Cinema, has cancelled the opening night of a special screening of 1980s film Back To The Future.
At 17:32:48 in SportAustralia's Anna Meares won her seventh Commonwealth medal as she took gold in the women's 500m time trial.
Harvard CitationBBC News, 2012. The flawed concept that saw voters reject city mayors [Online] (Updated 4th May 2012)
Available at: http://www.ukwirednews.com/news/1426645/The-flawed-concept-that-saw-voters-reject-city-mayors [Accessed 24th Jul 2014]
News In Other Categories
A list of possible gypsy and traveller sites in Teesside has been rejected by councillors.
Sir Bradley Wiggins was denied a first Commonwealth Games gold as Australia beat England in the final of the 4,000m team pursuit in Glasgow.
As if there isn't enough to organise for the big day.
The International Monetary Fund (IMF) has lowered its forecast for global economic growth this year, from 3.7% to 3.4%.
A drugs mule from Ayr has been jailed for three years after he admitted attempting to smuggle heroin worth almost £13,000 into Shetland.
One of Venezuela's main opposition leaders, Leopoldo Lopez, has told a judge in Caracas that his trial on charges of inciting violence will be a test for the country's democracy.