Court rules money must be paid back to Bank of Ireland
Category: Northern Ireland
Published: 4th May 2012 15:41:35
The Bank of Ireland has won a High Court ruling in its bid to recover a £1.5m loan given to three men for an east Belfast property development venture.
Summary judgment was secured was secured against John Crawford, Geoffrey Wilson and Joseph Donaldson.
The men took out a joint loan just months before Northern Ireland's property market crashed in 2007.
The money was borrowed to acquire land at Parkgate Avenue for £1.75m.
Mr Wilson, who runs a Dromore-based architectural salvage business, and Mr Donaldson, owner of Environmental Fabrications Ltd, each contributed £125,000.
Both men were clients of Mr Crawford, a Lisburn-based accountant and property developer who put in no money, according to court papers.
The balance was covered by the £1.5m loan agreed in November 2006.
After demanding repayment, the bank sought summary judgment against all three men, with interest and costs.
Mr Crawford took no part in the application, while the other two defended the action by claiming he had undue influence over them.
They also alleged breach of contract and/or a breach of duty of care on the part of the bank.
In his ruling, High Court Master Cathal McCorry noted the case involved buying land just before the collapse in the property market.
He said: "It is perhaps otiose to state it, but with the benefit of hindsight this was not a venture which was destined to be successful."
Master McCorry set out how Mr Crawford appeared to have initiated the venture and been its driving force.
"It was he who identified the site for purchase, made the initial approach to the First Trust Bank for funding, before shifting his attention in November 2006 to the plaintiff bank, with whom he carried out the negotiations on behalf of all three defendants," he said.
He ruled that Mr Wilson and Mr Donaldson had established a viable defence based on undue influence on the part of the bank's claim relating to accrued interest - some £332,411.
But according to Master McCorry this did not extend to the main amount owed.
He stated: "The plaintiff is therefore entitled to summary judgment... on the capital sum and interest, save for that portion of the claim relating to interest or charges.
"Insofar as the first named defendant (Mr Crawford) is concerned, he took no part in these proceedings, the defence based on undue influence would not be available to him in any event, and the plaintiff is therefore entitled to judgment in respect of the entire sum against him."
At 10:00:31 in EnglandA collection of eight Frogman bronze figures valued at more than £3,000 have been stolen from a gallery in Hertfordshire, police said.
At 09:58:47 in WalesTwo people have been taken to hospital following a house fire in Wrexham.
At 09:54:59 in HeadlinesPhilippine peacekeepers trapped by rebels in Syrian Golan Heights "under attack" - Philippine defence minister
At 09:54:52 in EnglandThousands of people are expected to attend the Jersey Live music festival at Trinity Showground this weekend.
At 09:45:43 in WalesThe concept of a military tank had been mooted for centuries by visionaries such as Leonardo da Vinci and HG Wells, yet it would take the horrific stalemate of the Western Front in World War One to make it a reality.
At 09:41:32 in HeadlinesA man has been stabbed to death in Notting Hill in west London, the Metropolitan Police has said.
At 09:41:12 in ScotlandPolice in Edinburgh have appealed for witnesses after a man was injured in a hit and run in the city centre.
At 09:39:30 in SportWales captain Sam Warburton says the players he has spoken to are happy with the new deal between the regions and the Welsh Rugby Union (WRU).
At 09:35:58 in Northern IrelandPolice in Armagh are investigating a suspected arson attack at a house in the city.
At 09:34:50 in EnglandIn a proudly British community 85 miles from the English coast, a distinctly French pastime is thriving.
Harvard CitationBBC News, 2012. Court rules money must be paid back to Bank of Ireland [Online] (Updated 4th May 2012)
Available at: http://www.ukwirednews.com/news/1426568/Court-rules-money-must-be-paid-back-to-Bank-of-Ireland [Accessed 30th Aug 2014]
News In Other Categories
George Galloway has left hospital after being treated for injuries he suffered in a street attack in west London.
Wales will qualify for the Euro 2016 finals, according to Mickey Thomas.
Firefighters are investigating the cause of a blaze in a former health and safety building in Aberdeen.
China has warned foreign countries against "meddling" in Hong Kong's politics ahead of a crucial announcement on the territory's election process.
Cheer/groan (delete according to mindset): The X Factor is back. Author Jeremy Clay tells the story of the show's Victorian forebear, where the hopefuls had to sing while carrying a pig.
Nine dead fox cubs have been found dumped at a Nottinghamshire nature reserve.