H5N1 research censorship 'problematic'
Published: 2nd May 2012 18:01:25
The editor of the world-leading scientific journal Nature says current procedures to assess and censor medical research potentially of use to terrorists need to be improved.
Dr Philip Campbell made his remarks to BBC News following the publication of controversial research into the bird flu virus H5N1.
Two research papers have raised the concern of anti-terrorist agencies.
One was submitted to Nature; the other to another leading journal, Science.
The Science paper has yet to appear.
Both pieces of research show that the H5N1 virus can relatively easily mutate into a form that might spread rapidly among the human population.
The studies had prompted the US National Security Advisory Board for Biotechnology (NSABB) to ask both journals last November to take out some sensitive parts of the research that it believed could be used by terrorists to develop a bio-weapon.
Many in the scientific community, including the researchers concerned, argued that the benefits of publishing the research in full outweighed the risks.
The purpose of the work was to help those trying to develop a vaccine against the virus and to track the spread of the disease. Many also considered it a breach of academic freedom.
The NSABB urged that a way be found to make deleted material available to legitimate researchers.
How do you decide which researchers should get the sensitive information. And how can you realistically ensure that once it is in a University environment that it wont go further?”
Discussions mediated by the World Health Organization earlier this year, however, concluded that there was no practical way of doing this, at least on a reasonable timescale, and so both Journals decided to publish the research.
Speaking for the first time on the issue, Dr Campbell said that the current process for establishing whether medical research should be censored was "very, very problematic".
"If we are to go down the censorship route, how do you decide which researchers should get the sensitive information? And how can you realistically ensure that once it is in a university environment that it won't go further?"
He also believes that the NSABB was too hasty to recommend censorship of the research.
"The process was too closed. People were having conversations only by phone and there was insufficient consultation of the researchers and of other experts," Dr Campbell told me.
So what's the best way to handle such a situation if it ever crops up again?
Dr Campbell believes that the NSABB and the WHO should continue to play an important role, but also he says that it's the responsibility of journal editors such as himself to consult the views of the community and the security agencies.
"We have access to the very best advice in such circumstances. I would also be willing to consider a more formal and collective process," he said.
"I can't readily conceive of how that might work in practice, but I'm happy to do anything that makes science more trusted where dangerous organisms are concerned."
Follow Pallab on Twitter
At 03:49:53 in HeadlinesThe oldest former player with Major League Baseball, Conrado "Connie" Marrero, has died in at home in Havana at the age of 102.
At 03:28:13 in WorldIndians are voting in the sixth phase of a marathon general election in which the governing Congress party is fighting the main opposition BJP.
At 03:13:22 in ScotlandThe last avalanche forecast of the latest Sportscotland Avalanche Information Service (SAIS) season has been published.
At 03:06:05 in ScotlandWhen Nicola Sturgeon joined the SNP, pursuing a career in politics was not her agenda.
At 02:56:02 in ScotlandTwo major curling competitions are under way in Dumfries just a couple of months after Scottish competitors scooped medals at the Winter Olympics.
At 02:54:55 in ScotlandParts of a fast reactor control room at Dounreay in Caithness look set to be dismantled and rebuilt at the Science Museum in London.
At 02:47:22 in ScotlandA new service of flights between Edinburgh and Stavanger has begun operation, it has been announced.
At 02:45:05 in ScotlandMajor restrictions on traffic and parking are to be introduced in Glasgow during the summer Commonwealth Games.
At 02:45:05 in WorldThe number of people who have contracted the Ebola virus in Guinea, according to the World Health Organization, has risen to 208 - and 136 of them have died. About half of these cases have been confirmed in a laboratory - earlier cases were not tested.
At 02:42:42 in ScotlandScottish councils have too little power and are too distant from the communities they serve, according to a report.
Harvard CitationBBC News, 2012. H5N1 research censorship 'problematic' [Online] (Updated 2nd May 2012)
Available at: http://www.ukwirednews.com/news/1426117/H5N1-research-censorship-problematic [Accessed 24th Apr 2014]
News In Other Categories
The oldest former player with Major League Baseball, Conrado "Connie" Marrero, has died in at home in Havana at the age of 102.
Eighteen-time US Olympic swimming champion Michael Phelps says concerns about weight gain were behind his decision to return to the sport.
The last avalanche forecast of the latest Sportscotland Avalanche Information Service (SAIS) season has been published.
The disappearance of a 96-year-old woman with Alzheimer's two years ago remains "really frustrating and very upsetting", her great-nephew has said.
An independent Scotland would have to fund pension costs of an additional £450 per working-age adult each year, the UK government has claimed.
Drones are becoming more common in our skies, performing a variety of tasks, from taking photos to monitoring crops and potentially even delivering broadband.