Widen over-the-counter pill access, says NHS report
Published: 26th Apr 2012 00:53:45
The contraceptive pill should be available at pharmacies without a GP prescription, including to some under-16s, suggests an NHS report.
A pilot scheme found a significant drop in emergency contraception after the launch of over-the-counter pill access.
The project looked at two London areas with high teenage pregnancy rates.
The report also suggests widening the service to include girls as young as 13 - two schemes currently offer this in the Isle of Wight and Manchester.
Since 2008, five pharmacies in Southwark and Lambeth have offered oral contraception without a GP prescription - these boroughs have some of the highest teenage conception rates in Europe, and the highest in London.
The study by NHS South East London judged the scheme a success. Its report also recommended providing the service to girls from the age of 13 as a way of helping to reduce teenage pregnancies.
However, it said: "At this stage there are no plans to extend the scheme to under-16 year olds in Southwark or Lambeth."
The two pilot schemes already offering this service in England have to meet strict guidelines. These include that the girl is able to understand the advice of a health professional, and the likelihood she will start having sex regardless of whether she gets access to contraception.
The report was uncovered by the GP magazine Pulse. Its editor, Richard Hoey, said: "Improving access to the pill is a key component of strategies to reduce teenage pregnancies, but there are obvious sensitivities to widening pharmacy schemes to girls as young as 13.
Without comprehensive research on real outcomes this strategy could well be like pouring petrol on flames”
"Where schemes like this are set up, it's important local GPs are involved, so they can be satisfied pharmacies are devoting the time needed to take a history and provide advice, and girls have a clear line to practices if they need further support."
The study found that around a quarter of the women receiving the pill in the scheme were aged under 19, with the majority aged 20-24. Forty-six per cent of the women who used the scheme had never taken the pill before.
Women using the service said they preferred getting the pill from the pharmacy, rather going to the GP for a prescription, because it was easier, quicker and no appointment was needed.
An anonymous user of the service said: "It is a quick way to get contraception, and it is very private, unlike a clinic where everyone will know what you are going there for."
While one pharmacy saw a significant drop in the use of emergency contraception after the pilot was launched, the report also found that a large proportion of women did not return for a subsequent pill supply- having gone back to emergency contraception. Many said this was because they did not have a regular partner.
'No clear evidence'
Currently it is not known if the service has helped reduce teenage pregnancies as conception data for the last three years is not available.
Dr Peter Saunders, from the Christian Medical Fellowship, is not convinced it will. He said: "There is no clear evidence from this study that it will reduce unplanned pregnancy and abortion and there is a real risk that, by encouraging more risk-taking behaviour, it could fuel the epidemic of sexually transmitted disease.
"Without comprehensive research on real outcomes this strategy could well be like pouring petrol on flames. We should instead be focusing on evidence-based strategies aimed at bring about real behaviour change."
A Department of Health spokesperson said: "Young people should think carefully before they have sex. They should also get good advice about contraception and sexually transmitted infections.
"The health professional must always encourage a young person to talk to their parents or another trusted adult about their sexual health."
Do you have any experience of the issues raised in this story? What is your reaction to the report? Send your comments to the BBC using the form below:
If you are happy to be contacted by a BBC journalist please leave a telephone number that we can contact you on. In some cases a selection of your comments will be published, displaying your name as you provide it and location, unless you state otherwise. Your contact details will never be published. When sending us pictures, video or eyewitness accounts at no time should you endanger yourself or others, take any unnecessary risks or infringe any laws. Please ensure you have read the terms and conditions.
Terms and conditions
At 19:47:12 in SportMichael Conlan and Steven Ward are among the Northern Ireland boxers entering the fray at the Commonwealth Games in Glasgow on Friday.
At 19:43:03 in EnglandThe family of a severely autistic teenager says it is hopeful he will return home to Cornwall after a minister criticised his care plan.
At 19:22:39 in SportNorthern Ireland's Lisa Kearney won a bronze medal in the -52kg women's judo category in Glasgow after beating Canadian Audree Francis-Methot.
At 19:22:07 in SportLewis Hamilton wants to stay with Mercedes beyond his current contract, which expires at the end of 2015.
At 19:18:46 in SportWest Ham's Andy Carroll has torn ligaments in his ankle and could be out of action for four months.
At 19:16:27 in SportAshley McKenzie claimed gold for England in the men's judo 60kg class at the Commonwealth Games in Glasgow.
At 18:55:19 in EnglandA boy with a form of dwarfism says he has been barred from buses five times in a fortnight in a row over his bike.
At 18:54:08 in EnglandTwo elevated seats for ambulance staff to watch for problems in the stadium were removed on the day of the tragedy at Hillsborough, the inquests heard.
At 18:51:48 in WalesA decision not to publish a document on the conclusions of a consultation on the planned M4 relief road has been criticised.
At 18:50:35 in EnglandA man accused of murdering a woman at a homeless shelter in Southampton has been cleared, after a pathologist said her death was not suspicious.
Harvard CitationBBC News, 2012. Widen over-the-counter pill access, says NHS report [Online] (Updated 26th Apr 2012)
Available at: http://www.ukwirednews.com/news/1424671/Widen-over-the-counter-pill-access-says-NHS-report [Accessed 24th Jul 2014]
News In Other Categories
A decision not to publish a document on the conclusions of a consultation on the planned M4 relief road has been criticised.
Michael Conlan and Steven Ward are among the Northern Ireland boxers entering the fray at the Commonwealth Games in Glasgow on Friday.
The immersive film-experience company, Secret Cinema, has cancelled the opening night of a special screening of 1980s film Back To The Future.
Myanmar has invited the aid agency Medecins Sans Frontieres to resume its work in Rakhine state, which has been plagued by sectarian violence.
The Republic of Ireland abstained from a vote to hold an official investigation into alleged war crimes in Gaza because it wanted swifter action using existing mechanisms, its foreign minister has said.
The family of a severely autistic teenager says it is hopeful he will return home to Cornwall after a minister criticised his care plan.