Government's Abu Qatada woes increase
Published: 18th Apr 2012 18:49:23
Has the latest row over the deportation of the radical Muslim cleric Abu Qatada come down to a misunderstanding about when midnight on Tuesday is?
Is it Monday night into Tuesday morning, or Tuesday night into Wednesday morning? The Home Office went for the first option, it seems, and the European Court of Human Rights the second.
This matters for two reasons: the credibility of the home secretary and how long it might take before Abu Qatada is put on a plane to Jordan - and whether he is released from prison in the mean time.
In her Commons statement, Theresa May suggested the government had a legally-watertight case to send Abu Qatada to Jordan, but it could take some months.
The home secretary, believing the deadline for an appeal to the court's Grand Chamber had passed, told MPs he could be removed from the UK "in full compliance of law."
But on Wednesday the court revealed it had received a request at 2200 BST on Tuesday evening, which it said was before the deadline.
Politically, it is potentially very awkward for the home secretary.
Her central pitch in the Commons was the government had secured a position of relative clarity: it could convince the European Court of Human Rights that Abu Qatada would get a fair trial in Jordan, and that evidence against him would not have been extracted by torture.
Yes, the process would take some time, but there was a clear process that had begun.
But it looks rather less clear now.
"I've been clear to everybody there were legal avenues for him to pursue," Mrs May told the BBC. "He has employed this delaying tactic. I'm not surprised, I don't think anybody should be surprised at that and I think he did this only after he had seen the strength of the case that we have for resuming his deportation to Jordan."
But shadow justice minister Chris Bryant shot back: "What seems to have happened is that the very basic details weren't done before the big fanfare of the announcement yesterday."
The reaction from some Conservative backbenchers has followed a pattern: support for the home secretary, criticism of Home Office civil servants.
Former shadow home secretary David Davis said the Home Office had "dropped the home secretary and the ministers in it."
Tory backbencher Mark Reckless was even more blunt: "Whoever is the home secretary, the Home Office is institutionally incompetent."
"So long as civil servants are unaccountable, so long as they are promoted however wrong they get things, things will not change," Mr Reckless added.
For some days, making a broader point, the outspoken Conservative MP Douglas Carswell has been suggesting civil servants are too powerful within government.
"Concerned about Sir Humphrey? It's not just me," is the headline of his latest blog. He even asked David Cameron about it at Prime Minister's Questions.
Meanwhile, the questions for the Home Office and the home secretary, that perpetually poisoned chalice of cabinet posts, keep coming.
The deportation of Abu Qatada is an intensely emotive issue. Red meat for newspapers, with big political ramifications.
Even the biggest supporters of the European Court of Human Rights acknowledge that "fast track" is not in its DNA. One person's procedural niceties and due process are another's never-ending pontificating.
It can lead to a feeling for some that decisions are forever getting kicked into the legal long grass.
The political danger for the government is that the grass might just have got even longer.
At 10:57:15 in SportSalisbury City's application to join the Wessex League has been rejected.
At 10:55:56 in ScotlandThe operators of a ski chair-lift at the centre of an accident which left eight people injured will not face prosecution.
At 10:54:20 in SportNorwich City have signed Falkirk midfielder Conor McGrandles for an undisclosed fee.
At 10:52:08 in ScotlandA row has broken out over plans for a multi-million pound flood defence scheme on the Whitesands in Dumfries.
At 10:52:03 in EnglandThe latest industrial action by London Underground (LU) workers over the dispute about plans to close all ticket offices and cut 960 jobs has been announced.
At 10:50:40 in WalesThe jury in the trial of a former race equality charity boss accused of fraud has retired to consider its verdict.
At 10:38:05 in HealthThe number of complaints made about NHS care in England increased to an average of 480 every day, official data shows.
At 10:35:30 in EnglandPeople's views are being sought on the latest changes to plans which set out where houses and businesses can be built in parts of south Somerset.
At 10:34:33 in SportBayern Munich are in talks to sign Xabi Alonso from Real Madrid and the midfielder is set to have a medical with the German club on Thursday.
At 10:32:09 in SportLeicester City goalkeeper Conrad Logan will remain on loan at League One club Rochdale until January.
Harvard CitationBBC News, 2012. Government's Abu Qatada woes increase [Online] (Updated 18th Apr 2012)
Available at: http://www.ukwirednews.com/news/1423191/Governments-Abu-Qatada-woes-increase [Accessed 28th Aug 2014]
News In Other Categories
The latest industrial action by London Underground (LU) workers over the dispute about plans to close all ticket offices and cut 960 jobs has been announced.
A senior aide to former US president Bill Clinton has accused Northern Ireland politicians of an "abysmal abdication of leadership".
The number of complaints made about NHS care in England increased to an average of 480 every day, official data shows.
The operators of a ski chair-lift at the centre of an accident which left eight people injured will not face prosecution.
A man who claims he was sexually abused by Bryan Singer has dropped his legal action against the X-Men film-maker.
The jury in the trial of a former race equality charity boss accused of fraud has retired to consider its verdict.