Do referees favour big football teams?
Published: 1st Apr 2012 00:03:31
Famous football teams benefit from favourable refereeing decisions when playing at home, it has been claimed this week. Is that true?
That was the complaint after Fulham were denied a penalty against Manchester United in a Premier League 1-0 defeat at Old Trafford, Manchester, last Monday.
The Fulham manager Martin Jol said afterwards that referees needed to be "brave" to give a visiting team a penalty at Old Trafford.
And two days later, Manchester City executive Patrick Vieira gave voice to a widely held belief when he said: "When United play at home, they may get some advantage that some other teams do not get."
The assumption among some fans has long been that big refereeing decisions tend to favour the big clubs when they play in front of their large and fervent home crowd.
"If you go to Spain it's the same, if you go to Italy, it's the same," said Vieira, who played for Arsenal for many years.
Emphasising that he hadn't seen the incident in the Fulham game and wasn't criticising Manchester Utd, he added: "It's something the teams who are used to winning get all the time, so we need to win games so we may have this kind of advantage in the future."
So is there any evidence that referees are more likely to make penalty decisions that favour big teams playing at home?
Listen to More or Less on BBC Radio 4 and the World Service, or download the free podcast
Among the current English Premier League teams which have played 50 or more home games since 2006, the statistics supplied by the sports data specialists Opta show that, on average, Manchester United have conceded one penalty every 12 home games.
This is more than Fulham, who have conceded roughly one penalty every 14 games at home.
So it is actually more common for a visiting team to get a penalty at Old Trafford than Craven Cottage.
Fulham are in fact among seven current Premier League clubs who have since 2006 conceded fewer penalties at home than Man Utd.
It's true that the team in the Premier League that has conceded the most penalties on average (one penalty every six matches) is one of the smaller clubs, Blackburn Rovers.
And also the team that has conceded the fewest (one penalty only every 18 games) is Chelsea, one of the top dogs. They have also won a penalty on average once every five games.
But there could be a far simpler explanation than referee bias, says a sports correspondent with a keen eye on the statistics, Bill Edgar of the Times newspaper.
"Given that Chelsea have been among the most successful clubs over that period, you would have expected them to have given away the fewest penalties simply because the opposition are generally weaker and therefore will spend less time in Chelsea's penalty area, so there will be less opportunity for them to win penalties," he says.
If the big clubs aren't necessarily conceding fewer penalties because of the referee, do they maybe have penalties awarded in their favour?
Manchester United have been awarded a penalty every 4.4 games, on average. This makes them the second-placed team in terms of the number of penalties won.
The first? Patrick Vieira's Manchester City. They were awarded a penalty every 3.93 games they played on average.
The two Manchester teams are the top two this season, battling it out for the Premier League trophy.
The team that ranks lowest in terms of the number of penalties won is Wolverhampton Wanderers who were awarded a penalty only every 13 matches on average.
But Vieira also complains that refs are biased towards the big clubs in Spain and Italy. And Real Madrid's manager Jose Mourinho is frequently up in arms over what he sees as bias in favour of Barcelona.
For the BBC, the sports statisticians at Opta have looked at every La Liga match involving Barcelona and Real Madrid since 2006.
The stats show that Real Madrid conceded one penalty roughly every 11 games in front of their home crowd, while Barcelona conceded one penalty in every 10 games.
So it's Jose Mourinho's own team, Real Madrid, who have a better penalty average.
And Real Madrid didn't just concede fewer penalties at home - they won more too - roughly one every four home games, compared with Barcelona's one in five.
But statistics alone do not tell us the truth about whether big teams really are favoured in the penalty area, says Edgar, who has an interesting solution.
"The only way you could really decide once and for all is to take disputed penalty instances at the home of each different Premier League team," he says.
"Then collect a panel of football experts and let them watch them. You would have the players' identities removed and the teams' identities removed and compare [the panel's] consensus with the decision the referees made.
"And if there was a considerable difference, then that would point to a bias among referees."
This kind of anonymised approach is possible in some fields. Orchestras famously introduced blind auditions where musicians played behind screens. When they did, the number of women hired rose sharply.
But it would be somewhat trickier to conduct blind experiments involving referees.
Mind you, some football fans will tell you the ref's blind anyway.
At 13:01:37 in HeadlinesThe National Union of Teachers' conference is to vote on Saturday on plans for a classroom walk-out in England and Wales this summer term.
At 12:57:28 in EnglandA man armed with a pickaxe has raided a jewellers in Guernsey, making off with diamond rings and necklaces.
At 12:54:07 in HeadlinesSouth Korean officials have said the recovery operation after Wednesday's ferry disaster may take two months.
At 12:46:25 in EnglandSunflowers are being planted in a North East borough to remember soldiers who lost their lives during the Great War.
At 12:44:48 in WalesTwo local historians have launched a World War One-related app to reveal the experiences of the people of Llanidloes in Powys in the conflict a century ago.
At 12:33:23 in WalesRoughly a month from now Wales will be voting in the European elections, beginning a two-year period when polls of one sort or another will come relatively thick and fast.
At 12:31:45 in SportLiverpool's title bid is "ahead of schedule", the owner of the table-topping Premier League club has said.
At 12:25:38 in SportMercedes driver Lewis Hamilton admits he starts Sunday's Chinese Grand Prix as strong favourite after qualifying on pole position.
At 12:18:51 in Northern IrelandTwo cars and two homes have been damaged in an arson attack in Banbridge, County Down.
At 12:14:40 in EnglandOne man has been left with head injuries and another with knife wounds in two separate assaults in Liverpool.
Harvard CitationBBC News, 2012. Do referees favour big football teams? [Online] (Updated 1st Apr 2012)
Available at: http://www.ukwirednews.com/news/1419962/Do-referees-favour-big-football-teams [Accessed 19th Apr 2014]
News In Other Categories
An 87-year-old man who fell off a pier into the sea as he rode his mobility scooter has died.
Former BBC presenter Derek Cooper, who founded long-running radio show The Food Programme, has died aged 88.
Taxpayers' personal data could be shared with private firms under plans drawn up by Revenue & Customs (HMRC).
The chair of the panel set up to advise the NHS and ministers on the governance of patient information has told the BBC the Care.data programme was mishandled.
Two cars and two homes have been damaged in an arson attack in Banbridge, County Down.
A man armed with a pickaxe has raided a jewellers in Guernsey, making off with diamond rings and necklaces.