Vitamin E 'may be bad for bones'
Published: 5th Mar 2012 07:36:11
Vitamin E supplements may interfere with the process that keeps bones healthy, suggest Japanese scientists.
Writing the journal Nature Medicine, the Keio University team said mice given large doses had lower bone mass - if the same was true in humans, fracture-risk would be reduced.
Vitamin E is found in oils, green vegetables such as spinach and broccoli and in almonds and hazelnuts.
But a UK expert said supplements could be problematic.
The relationship between nutrients such as vitamin D and bone health are well established, but there is far less research which looks at the role of vitamin E.
The research at Keio University in Tokyo looked at what happened when mice had not enough vitamin E, and what happened when they were given supplements.
There is increasing evidence that taking supplements doesn't do any good, and if anything, may be doing harm”
Although some early studies suggested that consumption of the vitamin had a positive effect on bone mass, the Japanese team found the reverse was true, with bone health improving in the deficient mice, and losing bone mass when given supplements.
The size and density of bones in the body is not fixed in adulthood, but dependent on a balance between cells which lay down new bone, called osteoblasts, and cells which strip it away, called osteoclasts.
The researchers suggested that vitamin E could encourage the formation of osteoclast cells, which meant more bone was lost than would be laid down.
Similar experiments in rats, including work published in 2010, found the opposite results to the latest study, even suggesting that vitamin E could be useful as a bone-growth promoting treatment for older people.
But Dr Helen Macdonald, who researches the influence of nutrition on bone health at Aberdeen University, said that there were a small number of studies, including her own, which found negative effects.
She stressed there was no reason for people to change their diet to avoid the relatively small amounts of vitamin E contained in it.
She said: "However, vitamin E supplements involve doses far higher than those in a normal diet.
"There is increasing evidence that taking supplements doesn't do any good, and if anything, may be doing harm."
At 13:01:37 in HeadlinesThe National Union of Teachers' conference is to vote on Saturday on plans for a classroom walk-out in England and Wales this summer term.
At 12:57:28 in EnglandA man armed with a pickaxe has raided a jewellers in Guernsey, making off with diamond rings and necklaces.
At 12:54:07 in HeadlinesSouth Korean officials have said the recovery operation after Wednesday's ferry disaster may take two months.
At 12:46:25 in EnglandSunflowers are being planted in a North East borough to remember soldiers who lost their lives during the Great War.
At 12:44:48 in WalesTwo local historians have launched a World War One-related app to reveal the experiences of the people of Llanidloes in Powys in the conflict a century ago.
At 12:33:23 in WalesRoughly a month from now Wales will be voting in the European elections, beginning a two-year period when polls of one sort or another will come relatively thick and fast.
At 12:31:45 in SportLiverpool's title bid is "ahead of schedule", the owner of the table-topping Premier League club has said.
At 12:25:38 in SportMercedes driver Lewis Hamilton admits he starts Sunday's Chinese Grand Prix as strong favourite after qualifying on pole position.
At 12:18:51 in Northern IrelandTwo cars and two homes have been damaged in an arson attack in Banbridge, County Down.
At 12:14:40 in EnglandOne man has been left with head injuries and another with knife wounds in two separate assaults in Liverpool.
Harvard CitationBBC News, 2012. Vitamin E 'may be bad for bones' [Online] (Updated 5th Mar 2012)
Available at: http://www.ukwirednews.com/news/1415612/Vitamin-E-may-be-bad-for-bones [Accessed 19th Apr 2014]
News In Other Categories
A man armed with a pickaxe has raided a jewellers in Guernsey, making off with diamond rings and necklaces.
An 87-year-old man who fell off a pier into the sea as he rode his mobility scooter has died.
Two local historians have launched a World War One-related app to reveal the experiences of the people of Llanidloes in Powys in the conflict a century ago.
Former BBC presenter Derek Cooper, who founded long-running radio show The Food Programme, has died aged 88.
Taxpayers' personal data could be shared with private firms under plans drawn up by Revenue & Customs (HMRC).
The chair of the panel set up to advise the NHS and ministers on the governance of patient information has told the BBC the Care.data programme was mishandled.