BBC drama offensive to British troops, says Army head
Published: 21st Nov 2010 04:05:37
The head of the British army has complained to the BBC about a drama showing bullying among troops in Afghanistan, calling it "deeply offensive to all those serving".
Sir Peter Wall has written to BBC director general Mark Thompson about the programme, Accused, said the MoD.
The episode features a corporal who bullies two friends who join the army, one of whom goes on to commit suicide.
The BBC said it was in no way an attempt to denigrate the Army.
The writer of the series, Bafta-winning TV dramatist Jimmy McGovern, has said that Accused is a work of fiction and that he had the greatest respect for British soldiers.
McGovern, who also created Cracker and The Street, said: "As a dramatist, I was interested in exploring how soldiers have to be at a certain mindset to kill.
"It is not my intention to slur British soldiers, for whom I have the greatest respect. At the heart of the drama is my belief in the sanctity of life."
There are fears that those watching it will believe this is what is really happening to their loved ones”
The episode is one of a six-part series following different people accused of crimes as they await the verdict of their trials. It stars Mackenzie Crook as a bullying corporal.
The Ministry of Defence said Sir Peter, the Chief of the General Staff, believed the episode was offensive to both troops and their families.
A spokesman said: "There are fears that those watching it will believe this is what is really happening to their loved ones.
"We have asked the BBC to make it clear that this is a fictitious programme, is not accurate and that the Army has nothing to do with making it."
A BBC spokeswoman confirmed that Mr Thompson had received a critical letter from Sir Peter and had responded, but would not release the director general's reply.
She said: "In the promotion of this new drama series... it has been made clear that Accused is a work of fiction.
"It is in no way an attempt to denigrate the servicemen and women of the British Army."
Last week prominent 2003 Iraq war veteran Colonel Tim Collins said the drama "fails the soldiers on the front line" and "abjectly fails the responsibility test".
Col Collins gained worldwide recognition for the eve-of-battle speech he gave his men in the Royal Irish Regiment in March 2003.
The decorated soldier, who retired from the Army in 2004, attacked the episode for its "gratuitous violence" and use of "foul and abusive language".
"There is no point to Accused except to try to shock," he told the Radio Times.
Best known as the creator of crime drama Cracker, McGovern has also written dramas about the 1989 Hillsborough disaster and the Bloody Sunday shootings of 1972.
At 00:57:36 in WorldFrom the sharp and potentially painful points on a kidney stone, to a head louse egg firmly glued to a hair follicle - the annual Wellcome Image Awards celebrate the best in science imaging talent and techniques. Take a close-up look at some of the winning images.
At 00:52:03 in WorldIt's a busy Monday night at Whispers strip bar in the oil boomtown of Williston, North Dakota.
At 00:47:53 in EnglandA silver Roman bracelet found in Cumbria is to go on show.
At 00:47:41 in WorldIn an emotional speech in Kiev on Sunday, former Russian oil tycoon Mikhail Khodorkovsky - recently released from 10 years in jail - told the Maidan "there is another Russia", one opposed to military action in Ukraine. Russian writer and broadcaster Andrei Ostalski agrees but says it's a small and embattled community.
At 00:46:18 in HealthWomen who suffer swelling following breast cancer treatment should be encouraged to exercise, say experts.
At 00:43:16 in WorldOn 6 February, Abdul Waheed Majeed, from Crawley in West Sussex, drove a truck bomb into the gates of a prison in Syria. Does his death represent everything that the government fears about radicalisation on a foreign battlefield?
At 00:38:46 in HealthSix mental health organisations in England are warning that NHS cuts are putting lives at risk.
At 00:38:33 in BusinessThe Confederation of British Industry says the government should make careers in science, technology, engineering and maths (STEM) more attractive.
At 00:38:18 in PoliticsChildren in residential care in England are being sent too far away from their own communities and families, a committee of MPs has said.
At 00:38:04 in HeadlinesUp to 60 Shanghai maths teachers are to be brought to England to raise standards, in an exchange arranged by the Department for Education.
Harvard CitationBBC News, 2010. BBC drama offensive to British troops, says Army head [Online] (Updated 21st Nov 2010)
Available at: http://www.ukwirednews.com/news/109659/BBC-drama-offensive-to-British-troops-says-Army-head [Accessed 12th Mar 2014]
News In Other Categories
Children in residential care in England are being sent too far away from their own communities and families, a committee of MPs has said.
From the sharp and potentially painful points on a kidney stone, to a head louse egg firmly glued to a hair follicle - the annual Wellcome Image Awards celebrate the best in science imaging talent and techniques. Take a close-up look at some of the winning images.
The family of a pensioner who died has demanded an inquiry into all hospitals under the control of a south Wales health board.
A silver Roman bracelet found in Cumbria is to go on show.
Women who suffer swelling following breast cancer treatment should be encouraged to exercise, say experts.
Arsenal midfielder Mesut Ozil is facing "at least a few weeks" out after injuring his hamstring in Tuesday's Champions League exit at Bayern Munich.