Steel's Lords bill 'not alterative to government's'
Published: 16th Jul 2012 14:24:45
Former Liberal leader Lord Steel has insisted his parliamentary bill to cut the membership of the House of Lords is not an "alternative" to the government's reform programme.
His proposals, including forced retirement for those who fail to attend or are convicted of crimes, were passed by peers last week.
Meanwhile, the government is struggling to promote plans for elected peers.
But Lord Steel said his own bill was only a "small start" on reform.
Liberal Democrats within the coalition are pushing for Lords reform, including electing 80% of peers and almost halving the total number to 450.
But many Conservatives oppose the plans, with 93 MPs rebelling against the government in a vote last week - the largest such act of defiance since the government was formed in 2010.
Lord Steel has tabled a separate bill, which would allow the voluntary retirement of peers. It would also impose retirement on those who failed to attend enough sessions in the Lords or are convicted of crimes.
On Friday peers passed a motion of commitment to discharge the bill - which means it has passed its committee stage. There will be no report stage and it will now move to third reading, after which it would go before MPs.
Similar proposals have already been debated and passed to the Commons in the previous session.
The developments have led some observers to suggest Lord Steel's proposals could represent a way for the government to alter the Lords while preserving the coalition.
But Lord Steel, who was Liberal leader from 1976 to 1988, told BBC Radio 4's World at One: "It's not an alternative to the government's proposals. It's a small start on sensible reforms that could take place now."
The government's plans would see peers elected for 15-year terms, with one third of seats to be filled every five years. This would begin in 2015.
Lord Steel said: "The government's proposals don't come into effect until 2025."
He added that removing peers who only attend infrequently would "take away 10% [of members] at a stroke".
The dispute over the government's Lords proposals has added to speculation about when the coalition will end in the run-up to the next general election, planned for 2015.
Lord Steel said there would "have to be a break" at some stage, adding that the Liberal-Labour pact of the late 1970s had ended about six months before the 1979 election, to allow the two parties to campaign separately.
He said: "I would imagine something of the same will happen again."
Harvard CitationBBC News, 2012. Steel's Lords bill 'not alterative to government's'. [Online] (Updated 16 Jul 2012)
Available at: http://www.ukwirednews.com/news.php/1440788-Steels-Lords-bill-not-alterative-to-governments [Accessed 10th May 2013]
At 19:48:34 in HeadlinesDoctors have closed the main hospital in Nigeria's north-eastern city of Maiduguri in protest at alleged police assaults on staff and p...
At 19:47:56 in EnglandNail bombs used to cause explosions in three houses in Staffordshire were made by a group of men in a barn, a court has heard....
At 19:35:46 in EnglandNine councillors have split from the Labour party in Harrow, north-west London, amid racism claims, leaving the council with no party in con...
At 19:24:18 in HeadlinesAli Abdulemam, a prominent blogger in Bahrain, has been smuggled out of the troubled Gulf kingdom and taken refuge in the UK, the BBC has le...
At 19:06:48 in EnglandThe second of two men being hunted by police after a prison van escape on 30 April has been recaptured, Greater Manchester Police have said....
At 19:03:37 in HeadlinesAriel Castro, the man accused of holding three women hostage for about a decade in Ohio, fathered a child who was also rescued from his hous...
At 19:02:55 in Northern IrelandThe Ulster Unionist leader says he is pulling out of a conference organised by Sinn Fein in protest at remarks by one of its ministers, John...
At 18:53:27 in ScotlandAlmost 50 people have been arrested across Scotland after being found to be working illegally....
At 18:35:56 in EnglandBristol's Labour party is expected to sign up to the mayor's cross-party cabinet, the BBC understands. ...
At 18:33:02 in EnglandA series of explosions in a fire at a disused warehouse in a Derbyshire town were caused by a gas cylinder, said the fire service....
News In Other Categories
A British Olympic sailor has died after a Swedish catamaran capsized during a training session for the America's Cup in San Francisco B...
Almost 50 people have been arrested across Scotland after being found to be working illegally....
The body of a whale has been removed from a mid Wales beach following a post-mortem examination....
Doctors have closed the main hospital in Nigeria's north-eastern city of Maiduguri in protest at alleged police assaults on staff and p...
Nail bombs used to cause explosions in three houses in Staffordshire were made by a group of men in a barn, a court has heard....
A new drama about the UK's coalition government by playwright David Edgar is to premiere at the Chichester Festival Theatre in June....