Arms sales to authoritarian regimes need review, say MPs
Published: 13th Jul 2012 01:44:52
Arms sales to authoritarian regimes should be reviewed to ensure equipment was not used to repress citizens, MPs have urged.
They asked ministers to explain whether the 600 licences to Arab countries complied with UK government policy.
They also strongly rebuked ministers for classifying equipment such as sniper rifles and armoured fighting vehicles as "crowd control goods".
A Foreign Office minister said it was wrong to suggest controls were lax.
The criticisms were made by the Commons arms export control committees, made up of members of the business, defence, foreign affairs and international development committees.
The report said the revocation on human rights grounds of an unprecedented 158 licences since the start of the Arab Spring last year showed that ministers needed to be more cautious about issuing them.
The government's been open with MPs about the arms exports licences that have been granted over the past year.
But the long list of military equipment and, more importantly, the names of those countries who have been sold it appears hard to justify.
For example, why are arms export licences still active for Syria, Iran, China and Bahrain? And why does the government describe the sale of lethal weapons, such as sniper rifles and sub-machine guns, as "crowd control goods"?
The committees highlight the fundamental problem, and contradiction in the government's position.
On the one hand chastising "authoritarian regimes" for their poor record on human rights. But, on the other, allowing and even promoting arms sales to those very same countries. Ministers have probably been more honest than many other nations about what it allows to be exported.
Arms sales will always been controversial. But a report like this opens up the government to charges of hypocrisy.
"Whilst the promotion of arms exports and the upholding of human rights are both legitimate government policies, the government would do well to acknowledge that there is an inherent conflict between strongly promoting arms exports to authoritarian regimes whilst strongly criticising their lack of human rights at the same time," it said.
"Whilst the government's statement that 'respect for human rights and fundamental freedoms are mandatory considerations for all export licence applications' is welcome, those considerations do not appear to have weighed sufficiently heavily on either the present government or its predecessor."
It is wrong to allege that in the run-up to the Arab Spring UK export controls were lax”
The report expressed particular concern about the licences still valid for Arab countries, including 124 for Egypt and 97 for Bahrain as well as nine for Syria covering chemicals, cryptographic equipment, and £200,000-worth of "all-wheel drive vehicles with ballistic protection".
The report called on ministers to extend their review of arms export policy to the Middle East and North Africa - ordered in the wake of the Arab Spring - to cover authoritarian regimes and countries of human rights concern around the world.
It was also sharply critical of the way lethal equipment - including shotguns, small arms, semi-automatic pistols, assault rifles, sniper rifles, submachine guns, ammunition, armoured personnel carriers and armoured fighting vehicles - were classified as "crowd control goods" for licensing purposes.
"The committees recommend that the government discontinues the use of the phrase 'crowd control goods' in this context, which as well as being misleading is also profoundly disrespectful to the thousands of unarmed civilians in the Arab Spring countries who have courageously demonstrated for human rights and fundamental freedoms and have put their lives at risk in doing so," it said.
Foreign Office Minister Alistair Burt said the government assessed the licences according to its strict policy about taking into account concerns and risks.
"It is wrong to allege that in the run-up to the Arab Spring UK export controls were lax," he said.
"When the licences in question were issued, they were properly assessed in light of the prevailing circumstances. Once the circumstances changed, the risk was reassessed and licences were revoked.
"This is evidence of a system that is working, not failing. There is no evidence that equipment supplied by the UK was used to facilitate internal repression during the Arab Spring."
He added that the government's review of arms export policy was not confined to North Africa and the Middle East and covered "every kind of regime and every kind of country".
He said: "It would therefore be wrong to infer that we are failing to pay appropriate ministerial attention to exports to all countries of concern, whether in the Middle East or elsewhere."
Harvard CitationBBC News, 2012. Arms sales to authoritarian regimes need review, say MPs. [Online] (Updated 13 Jul 2012)
Available at: http://www.ukwirednews.com/news.php/1440289-Arms-sales-to-authoritarian-regimes-need-review-say-MPs [Accessed 18th May 2013]
At 11:52:06 in EnglandA West Midlands theatre will be demolished as part of £10m regeneration plans, a council has said....
At 11:51:12 in Northern IrelandThe family of a police officer who was murdered during a robbery in the Irish Republic earlier this year is set to receive a special medal i...
At 11:40:11 in EnglandA woman who disappeared while swimming off the Lincolnshire coast was found alive after a major search operation....
At 11:26:57 in WalesA footpath is likely to remain closed for some time after the collapse of a stone wall near a historic hotel in Denbighshire....
At 11:21:04 in Northern IrelandA 14-year-old girl has been punched in the face and knocked to the ground during a mugging in Belfast....
At 11:15:29 in EnglandFootball legends will be playing against British Army players at Reading's Madejski Stadium later to raise money for two military chari...
At 11:04:32 in WalesA new £5m waterside development in Colwyn Bay is being launched with a weekend of celebrations....
At 10:55:00 in HeadlinesThe European Commission is to ban the use of refillable bottles and dipping bowls of olive oil at restaurant tables from next year....
At 10:44:36 in Northern IrelandA second day of talks aimed at improving relations between loyalist and republican communities and the police is taking place in Wales....
At 10:35:45 in HeadlinesNorth Korea has fired three short-range missiles from its east coast, South Korea's defence ministry said....
News In Other Categories
The Swedish city of Malmo is gearing up to host the Eurovision Song Contest final with 26 countries set to perform for millions of TV viewer...
Most of us will probably think of psychopaths as dangerous knife-wielding maniacs who are better off behind bars....
The family of a police officer who was murdered during a robbery in the Irish Republic earlier this year is set to receive a special medal i...
A new £5m waterside development in Colwyn Bay is being launched with a weekend of celebrations....
The European Commission is to ban the use of refillable bottles and dipping bowls of olive oil at restaurant tables from next year....
With the doors to its brand new £1million training centre officially open, one of the UK's leading apprentice training providers, Bristol ba...