Marion Millican murder jury hears final arguments
Published: 2nd Jul 2012 18:19:50
The jury in the trial of a 49-year-old Co Antrim man who claims he accidentally shot his former lover while intending to kill himself have heard final submissions in the case.
Fred McClenaghan, from Broad Street, Magherafelt, denies murdering the mother of four on 11 March 11 last year.
Prosecution lawyer Neil Connor began and ended his submissions by attacking the suggestion that the death of Mrs Millican was the result of an accident.
McClenaghan had, said Mr Connor, in the months before the shooting, repeatedly told counsellors of his wish and dreams of wanting to kill his ex-girlfriend and himself, and that if he could not have her, then nobody would..."and that's what he did members of the jury, he made sure of that".
However, the lawyer also said that despite his protestations of wanting to kill himself and while Mrs Millican now lay dead, McClenaghan was still very much alive.
He added that according to a top psychiatrist "he is now 'content' and only gets tense from time to time and is no longer depressed", despite the fact he had killed someone he claimed to have loved.
Mr Connor said the medical and forensic evidence showed that the shooting was no accident, the defence had only provided some "self-serving second-hand accounts... but not one shred of direct evidence" to undermine or contradict the prosecution case.
He added that such was the nature of the case, that it "cries out for an answer" and that it was difficult to conceive of a case "where the demand for answers and explanation is more".
There was nothing, claimed Mr Connor, stopping McClenaghan from getting into the witness box and telling the court what happened that fateful day, save he had no answer to give to the prosecution case.
"The cries for an explanation are deafening," Mr Connor, told the jury," and yet you have heard none".
The lawyer also dismissed defence arguments that McClenaghan was suffering from diminished responsibility at the time of the shooting and therefore was not responsible for his actions.
Mr Connor said McClenaghan was not mentally ill, but was motivated by anger and jealousy and feelings of resentment and rejection and that he knew what he was doing and therefore must bear "full responsibility for what he did".
Defence QC John McCrudden began his submissions by likening McClenaghan's shooting of Mrs Millican to the book and film The Perfect Storm where a number of seemingly unrelated events and elements had come together to result in a terrible tragedy.
In McClenaghan's case, it was the culmination of a number of factors, beginning with sexual abuse as a youngster, heart problems in later life, and his inability to cope with emotional stresses, in particular the break-up of his relationship with Mrs Millican.
However, Mr McCrudden told the jury before even considering McClenaghan's mental state at the time, they had to consider the evidence, and reminded them McClenaghan was an innocent man, and that it was not for him to disprove the prosecution case.
"In this case a young woman has died and died tragically and in terrible circumstances," said Mr McCrudden, but he added it was also a case, "shot through with emotion and shot through with tragedy" but also "... a case shot through with reasonable doubt".
Mr McCrudden went on to dismiss the forensic evidence as "a train wreck" in which not only had internationally recognised agreed protocols been abandoned, but also national standards as to the testing of the shotgun with no data or notes being recorded.
The lawyer further claimed that prosecution forensic experts had "driven a coach and four" through their own national standards leaving "the terrible spectre, the real possibility, that this gun did go off during a struggle" between McClenaghan and Mrs Millican as he had claimed.
Mr McCrudden said this gave rise to "a reasonable doubt, which we say can never be erased from this case".
The lawyer claimed that the jury were also dealing with a case in which there were "two hair-triggers, the one on this very dodgy shotgun and McClenaghan".
It was agreed, said Mr McCrudden, and there was no question that McClenaghan was a seriously mentally ill man, and in the circumstances he was The Perfect Storm and all hell was set to be let loose in that launderette in Portstewart".
However, Mr McCrudden concluded by telling the jury would not have to consider that aspect of the case as the prosecution had "fallen at the first hurdle, they don't even come near erasing the reasonable doubt in this case".
Harvard CitationBBC News, 2012. Marion Millican murder jury hears final arguments. [Online] (Updated 02 Jul 2012)
Available at: http://www.ukwirednews.com/news.php/1438182-Marion-Millican-murder-jury-hears-final-arguments [Accessed 19th June 2013]
At 19:47:26 in HeadlinesOne in nine US bridges - more than 66,000 in total - are structurally deficient, a report has found....
At 19:45:43 in HeadlinesBrazilian police have fired tear gas and rubber bullets to disperse protesters in the city of Fortaleza, as unrest continues across the coun...
At 19:33:31 in WorldUS Secretary of State John Kerry has spoken by phone with Afghan President Hamid Karzai to try to defuse tension, an Afghan government spoke...
At 19:32:47 in BusinessThe US Federal Reserve has maintained the rate of its asset purchase programme at $85bn (£54bn) a month, aimed at boosting the economy....
At 19:26:21 in EnglandTwo workers at a care home in Buckinghamshire asked for forgiveness after being caught sleeping during their night shift, a court has heard....
At 19:24:15 in EnglandFormer newspaper boss Eddy Shah "never touched" a young girl he is accused of raping, a co-defendant has told jurors....
At 19:21:03 in WalesA snack bar manufacturer is to move its main production plant from north to south Wales....
Mars' atmosphere could have been rich in oxygen four billion years ago - well before Earth's air became augmented with the gas....
At 18:55:19 in Northern IrelandThe first public hearings of the historical institutional abuse inquiry should begin in January 2014, the inquiry chairman has told a Northe...
At 18:53:49 in HeadlinesEgypt's tourism minister has said he will quit in protest at the appointment of a governor in the city of Luxor with links to an Islami...
News In Other Categories
The government has rejected Labour calls for specially-trained teachers to be brought in to educate children about the dangers of internet p...
A rodent that never gets cancer could hold the key to preventing or treating malignant tumours, say scientists....
Sally Gardner, a dyslexic author once branded "unteachable" at school, has won the prestigious Carnegie Medal for her book Maggot ...
Slim Whitman, the American country singer known for his yodelling abilities has died at the age of 90....
With the doors to its brand new £1million training centre officially open, one of the UK's leading apprentice training providers, Bristol ba...
UK telecoms regulator Ofcom is to launch an investigation into BSkyB over the supply of its sports channels to rival broadcasters....