Lianne Smith killed children 'out of love' court hears
Published: 20th Jun 2012 18:38:31
A British woman killed her two children in a hotel room "out of love for them", a court in Spain has heard.
Lianne Smith has admitted smothering Rebecca, five, and 11-month-old Daniel in Lloret de Mar in May 2010.
The Provincial Court in Girona is determining whether the 45-year-old is criminally responsible for murder.
Her defence is seeking an acquittal, claiming she was in a state of "psychiatric disturbance" when the tragedy happened.
The deaths happened a few days after Ms Smith's partner, Martin Smith, was extradited to the UK on charges of sexually abusing her eldest daughter by another relationship.
Forensic psychiatrist Itziar Idiaquez Alberdi, who interviewed Ms Smith four times, said: "She believed the children would be taken away from her and institutionalised.
"For her this was worse than death. She was living in permanent fear of what might happen.
"She killed them out of love. She loved the children."
Psychiatrist Harry Barker, who treated Ms Smith in Girona prison, said the 45-year-old had asked Rebecca if she would prefer to live a few very happy days with her mother or a long time without her, and Rebecca had replied that she wanted to stay with her mother.
He added that Ms Smith saw the deaths of her children as "an unavoidable catastrophe".
After hearing the evidence, prosecutor Victor Pillado Quintas agreed that she was suffering "pathological emotional dependence and a psychotic disorder which impaired her faculties" but argued that she was criminally responsible for the deaths.
"I do not think there is a more abominable act than ending the life of a small child," he said.
"But if there is something which is even more horrid, more vile, more despicable than taking the life of a small child, it is that a mother should take the life of her own small child.
"During this trial it has been said that the prosecution is out to get blood, to get punishment for punishment's sake.
"All the prosecution wants is for justice to be done."
The hearing had previously heard that she had tried to take her own life after the deaths.
Her partner, Martin Smith, was convicted of raping a girl under 16 and jailed.
The 46-year-old former TV psychic, originally from North Shields, North Tyneside, was found hanged in his cell in January.
The couple, who share the same surname but were not married, left Lichfield, Staffordshire, for Spain in 2007 with Rebecca. Daniel was born in Spain.
Previously they had been living in Cumbria, where the sex offences occurred.
Harvard CitationBBC News, 2012. Lianne Smith killed children 'out of love' court hears. [Online] (Updated 20 Jun 2012)
Available at: http://www.ukwirednews.com/news.php/1435876-Lianne-Smith-killed-children-out-of-love-court-hears [Accessed 18th May 2013]
At 06:40:48 in EnglandSun, sounds and sangria or music, mud and mayhem? ...
At 05:50:58 in HeadlinesFlooding and landslides across nine southern Chinese provinces have killed more than 50 people and left 14 missing, officials say....
At 05:28:08 in HeadlinesRemarks said to have been made by one of David Cameron's closest allies, at a private dinner, find their way on to the front page of se...
At 04:18:27 in HeadlinesAfghan MPs are to debate a law to prevent violence against women, amid a fierce argument between leading Afghan women over tactics. ...
At 04:05:07 in EnglandThe widow of former KGB spy Alexander Litvinenko has called for the upcoming inquest into his death to be abandoned and replaced with a publ...
At 03:30:06 in EnglandThe education secretary is like a "fanatical personal trainer" who urges schools to jump higher and run faster, a head teachers...
At 03:19:09 in EnglandDerbyshire nurses, midwives and care givers are marking the anniversary of Florence Nightingale's birth by marching to Derby Cathedral....
At 03:11:54 in WorldNawaz Sharif's victory in Pakistan's general elections is being seen with some alarm in Afghanistan, where some fear it may mean m...
At 02:59:05 in HeadlinesOJ Simpson's former lawyer has rebutted claims by his former client he botched his defence in an armed robbery case....
At 02:43:34 in HeadlinesAbout 60 people have been injured, five critically, after a head-on, rush-hour collision between two commuter trains near New York City, off...
News In Other Categories
Legendary Indian batsman Rahul Dravid has spoken of his anguish after three players from the team he captains in the Indian Premier league w...
With the doors to its brand new £1million training centre officially open, one of the UK's leading apprentice training providers, Bristol ba...
A lorry driver from County Tyrone has been jailed for 14 years in Greece after being convicted for his part in smuggling herbal cannabis wor...
The education secretary is like a "fanatical personal trainer" who urges schools to jump higher and run faster, a head teachers...
Computers and smartphones have become a "digital dummy" used by parents to pacify their children, says a head teachers' leade...
The Swedish city of Malmo is gearing up to host the Eurovision Song Contest final with 26 countries set to perform for millions of TV viewer...